5 ms·
If Caucasian engineers at an American company created fried chicken, sumo wrestler and sushi filters for specific ethnic target markets they'd be accused of eth
by walrus01 10y ago
If Caucasian engineers at an American company created fried chicken, sumo wrestler and sushi filters for specific ethnic target markets they'd be accused of ethnic stereotypes and racism.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- colordrops 10y agoI don't think that's true based on personal experience working for foreign markets. Who exactly would be calling these engineers racist?
- nostromo 10y agoOther Americans, of course.
- walrus01 10y agogood luck creating a fried chicken filter targeted at south korea and convincing people it wasn't part of some thinly veiled "fried chickenz and watermelons" plot to insult a large percentage of the american population...
- vskarine 10y agoremember what happened when Snapchat had Bob Marley filter?
- mrmffh 10y agoPeople who don't understand what 'racist' means. Which is a lot of people today.
- yongjik 10y agoTo be fair, if a Japanese company launched sumo wrestler filters in Korea, I'm sure some people will find a way to be offended. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ (Also, never mention "Sea of Japan", or you'll be in deep trouble...)
- downandout 10y agoOnly Americans would accuse them of racism, because we Americans like to manufacture controversy. Regardless, you either give each market what it wants, or you will fail. If they were really that worried about such accusations, Snapchat could have created an Asian subsidiary company and had that company create and release an Asian version of it. Given that Snapchat is blocked in China, they should have done this anyway and created a version that was palatable to the Chinese government.
- Mizza 10y agoOnly on HN will you receive genuine advice to create a communication app specifically tailored for the censorship and surveillance purposes of an authoritarian government for profit.
- downandout 10y agoIf you dislike Chinese censorship, you can refuse to participate in their market, or you can have a seat at the table and try to work for change from the position of having a popular and valued service in their country. The latter is probably more effective. Snapchat isn't exactly the tool of choice for privacy-minded people anyway.
- cloudjacker 10y agoI specifically add things to my products that might trigger some ladies on black twitter so that it goes viral. I thought everyone was doing this.
- calbear81 10y agoProbably true; remember the controversy about the skin lightening filter? That would be a default filter in Asia where fair skin is aesthetically considered more beautiful.
- brobinson 10y ago>where fair skin is aesthetically considered more beautiful The first time I heard 一白遮三丑 was an eye-opening experience. I knew the stereotype but not how far it actually went.
- yongjik 10y agoI once heard a theory that whiter skins were considered more aesthetically pleasing in old days (in East Asia), because at that time everybody worked at fields, so being pale meant that your family is so rich that you don't have to work. It was something that couldn't be attained by most people. Fast forward to the industrial age: now poor women worked all day long in a factory, barely getting sunlight, while rich girls would visit beaches and sky resorts, tanning themselves. Suddenly, being slightly tanned is now considered "healthy" and, to some degree, "more beautiful". That said, most people still seem to like relatively whiter skin, just not 0xffffff.
- whack 10y ago> I once heard a theory that whiter skins were considered more aesthetically pleasing in old days (in East Asia), because at that time everybody worked at fields, so being pale meant that your family is so rich that you don't have to work. It was something that couldn't be attained by most people. > Fast forward to the industrial age: now poor women worked all day long in a factory, barely getting sunlight, while rich girls would visit beaches and sky resorts, tanning themselves. Suddenly, being slightly tanned is now considered "healthy" and, to some degree, "more beautiful". I actually heard this exact theory about skin perceptions in western countries, and I think it's regarded pretty well by sociologists/historians. Being "too pale" is an insult these days among Whites, and many people specifically go to tanning salons or lie in the sun, just to tan/darken their skin tone.
- 10y ago
- rtpg 10y agoIt's about context and how it's presented. The fried chicken thing as a sponsored filter would totally just make sense and be silly.
- Steko 10y agoThose poor Caucasian engineers, when will they ever break free from the chains of their imaginary PC shackles?