2 ms·
throughout the comments, people have commented about the necessity of work as if the only jobs required for society to function are 40 hour corporate office acc
by haroem 10y ago
throughout the comments, people have commented about the necessity of work as if the only jobs required for society to function are 40 hour corporate office accounting professionals and IT staff.
the entire concept vastly downplays the actual number of services people utilize and purchase. how do you automate a lawsuit? which robot knows how to install a new circuit breaker box? and even if a robot could hypothetically discover new oil fields who decides how it searches and where are these mythological solar powered oil field search bots that have close to unlimited range so nobody has to figure out what depot they're stashed in?
finally, how do I build a new computer and phone from scratch when no slave labor exists to create all the components that go into that design since apple and microsoft and samsung and sony all have to go out of business because nobody has any money to buy their devices?
I would google it, but they're out of business since ads don't work in a society without money.
the library card only goes so far. psychological thrillers to academic psychiatry, kids books to romance novels, newspaper articles going back 50 years, but somehow I don't think I'd be able to learn micro-computing circa 2016. It would be back to concepts circa 1980-1996 and the entire field would be tedious again.
yes. a work free world would be terrible. I've thought about it a lot because the better part of my life is spent figuring out how to work less. you notice over time the people who don't have a choice in automation and they get my respect because there's very little chance they're ever unemployed longer than a couple days in their lifetime.
- shkkmo 10y agoI'm not sure what argument you are making, you seem to be missing the point of the article. You seem to be saying a work-free world is not technically feasible without reducing economic output. I think if such a world is possible, it is quite far off and dependent on numerous advances in robotics and AI. However, the article is not trying to say such a world is feasible, but trying to make an argument about whether we should be imparting a value to work besides the economic value that work creates. (I.E. should we value work because it is necessary to provide purpose and happiness).
- slackstation 10y agoIt's not that there would be no work or that there would be no jobs or companies staffed with people. The point is that the average median person might not be good enough to get a job. If automation makes it so that only 20% of people are employed in any traditional sense that we recognize today; that world would be drastically different than the one we have. In that world, we have a path where we don't get rid of money but, just use taxes on large mega companies and redistibute that money as a basic income to people without a job. This keeps capitalism and the efficiencies it brings. With basic income, you still have advertising, you still have companies and you still have consumers buying things. There is still competition to push quality up and prices down. There is still the invisible hand of the market. It's elegant in that it achieves the goals of eliminating both poverty and forced labor to survive without eliminating the competition that makes the world so damned efficient and effective.