2 ms·
> It's just so far from reality as it stands today that it's not even worth talking about as anything other than science fiction We need to discuss this today,
by shkkmo 10y ago
> It's just so far from reality as it stands today that it's not even worth talking about as anything other than science fiction
We need to discuss this today, because we need to determine the path we will take forward.
1) Do we impede the adoption of automation to make sure there is work for everyone?
2) Do we have to keep the increasingly large numbers of unemployed mired in poverty to incentivize people to do the remaining necessary work?
3) Do we allow people the economic freedom to choose whether to work or not and then trust that the necessary work will get done because enough people want power and status?
I personally think 1) is a bad idea and will retard our progression. However, if you believe work is necessary for happiness and we have a duty to provide happiness for everyone, then 1) seems to be the only choice. (The article's point is to make an argument agains this option)
I do think we need a balance between 2) and 3). To me the unknown is how much economic freedom can we provide before we start losing economic output. I don't think we need to have a clear answer for this right now, but we can find the balance gradually by introducing a slowly increasing basic income.
- EdSharkey 10y agoWhatever our discussions on automation lead to, I hope we can consider the fragility angle. I'm with you on #1, but it seems to me that automation encourages too much dependency on the technology because of human nature. If there was some catastrophe and the populace was deprived of technology, I fear that most would be utterly helpless and endangered. I understand that the best person to take charge of the average individual is themselves, and ultimately one's continued survival is their responsibility. That said, life is pretty sublime for most people where I live and most of the time all needs are met - so survival ranks low on the priorities list. Perhaps the responsible thing to do would be to make it a part of a standard education to teach low-tech survival skills. Boy Scouts was the closest thing I had to this kind of training as a kid, and I still hang on to my boy scout manual if I need knowledge in an emergency. I try to buy food and manufactured goods made at the local level wherever possible to increase the chances that essentials can be provided if my area were to ever be cutoff from outside support for a long period.
- CydeWeys 10y ago#1 seems incredibly unlikely to happen, which is why it doesn't worry me. It would be very at odds with who is in power globally.
- alphapapa 10y ago> We need to discuss this today, because we need to determine the path we will take forward. Thanks, I needed a good laugh today. Seriously though, we can't even agree on what color to paint the shed. How are we going to agree on what path to take as an entire species on the whole planet? Besides that, who is "we"? You and me? The country you or I live in? The EU or the UN? What if someone decides to do something other than agreed upon? Go to war to stop someone from building a farming machine? What about when everyone has a 3D printer, and someone leaks a blueprint for a banned machine online? (Obviously, 3D printers will be banned, then, or licensed, or only allowed to run government-approved software that can print approved designs...and then programmers will be licensed and bonded, or compilers will be banned, or...) This thing is a huge ship with billions of tiny rudders all turning whichever direction they want. We're basically along for the ride.