5 ms·
I'm not a GTK user, so maybe I'm missing something here. And I certainly agree with the version number complaints. But these quotes trouble me: "what GTK really
by wpietri 10y ago
I'm not a GTK user, so maybe I'm missing something here. And I certainly agree with the version number complaints. But these quotes trouble me: "what GTK really needs to do is sit down and flesh out a decent API" and "And if you’re having to mess with your API on a continual basis, you’re doing it wrong. Like, the whole software development thing, all wrong."
I think there's an conceptual error here. There are a lot of bad reasons to change software, but I think there are two really good reasons: 1) circumstances change, and 2) we have learned something. Or conversely, I think the only time software can have a static design is when circumstances are static and you never learn anything.
There's this common notion that if people just sit down and think really hard, they will design the perfect thing. That's a mirage. The iPod went through more than a hundred physical revisions before launch. And it has changed a great deal in the 15 years since. Is that because Apple didn't just sit down and think enough? Nope. Even the humble paperclip evolved over decades. If perfect software ever happens, that belongs to a future age.
- digi_owl 10y agoHere is the rub, if you take a look at the Linux kernel you will see that they have managed, for the most part, to maintain backwards compatibility for a decade or more. You can probably still run ELF binaries today that you compiled back when they move to the format. Heck, you can even compile the kernel to support a.out of you are so inclined.
- qznc 10y agoAlan Cox https://plus.google.com/115250422803614415116/posts/hMT5kW8LKJk https://plus.google.com/115250422803614415116/posts/hMT5kW8L... > However it's not an Open Source disease its certain projects like Gnome disease - my 3.6rc kernel will still run a Rogue binary built in 1992. X is back compatible to apps far older than Linux.
- digi_owl 10y agoDo wonder if that claimed X compatibility holds up with recent Xorg versions, as they seem to enjoy ripping out code these days...
- throwanem 10y agoA couple years back I managed to get Open Genera talking to a reasonably modern (ca. 2013) X server, which has to count for something. In fact, getting it talking to the X server was practically the only aspect of the project in which I didn't have problems. Too, when I decided in a (thankfully transient) fit of madness to write my own window manager targeting whatever x.org package you got with Debian jessie around Q4 2015, I managed to do so based almost entirely on what I gleaned from a partial set of ancient X manuals which were already yellowing and musty when I picked them up at my city's free book exchange years ago, plus the manual and info pages that came with the system and the Emacs build I put on it. Not what you'd call an exhaustive evaluation, and maybe things have changed, but I'd say there is at least anecdotal reason for hope with regard to backward compatibility in X.org.
- wpietri 10y agoI think the Linux kernel is a bit of a special case. Processors have become boring[1]. What we've mainly wanted out of the Linux kernel is a stable server platform. But that stability is not without cost; a lot of innovation has happened by working around the kernel. E.g., virtualization, containerization. But "virtual server" is like "radio with pictures" or "horseless carriage". It's a sign that something new is coming, but we don't know quite what yet. [1] http://preshing.com/20120208/a-look-back-at-single-threaded-cpu-performance/ http://preshing.com/20120208/a-look-back-at-single-threaded-...
- digi_owl 10y agoExcept that the "new" have existed on mainframes for decades... It really feels like IT is just reinventing wheels at this point, because nobody involved seems to care at all about history of computing.
- teacup50 10y agoApple? They're the people that shipped transparent CPU emulation mechanism to keep their ABI working and avoid breaking customers. Twice.
- wpietri 10y agoSure. But they're also the people who recently decided a whole new programming language was necessary. And they're on, what, their 10th major iOS release? Which seems to fit with my point, which is that no matter how smart you are, you won't be able to "sit down" and design something perfect. And unlike Apple, most of us can't spin up large teams to try to hide the cost of change from our users. It would be nice if open source projects had $200 billion in cash sitting around, but that's not the world we live in. That's again not to say that GTK is doing anything right; I wouldn't know. My only point is that holding open source projects to impossible standards won't help anything.
- im_down_w_otp 10y agoAs someone who went through the the 68k -> PPC -> x86 transitions with shockingly minimal fuss (also even the MacOS -> OS X + Classic transitions) I wish I could upvote this comment a thousand times.
- speeder 10y agoI had a name conflict in an ios project... found out the header it conflicted with was from apple lisa era, meant to allow gui draw calls to work with quickdraw
- ryanmarsh 10y ago> but I think there are two really good reasons: 1) circumstances change, and 2) we have learned something Gtk has been around long enough that the boiling should have at least been reduced to a simmer by now.
- wpietri 10y agoI could well believe that. But assuming that GTK really should be at a simmer, I'd want to see an argument not for generic stability, but for areas of stability vs change. E.g., "Foo is now well understood, so that should be a stable core API. Bar, though, is an area that will keep evolving, so GTK should do A, B, and C." I'm not opposed to providing stable APIs. I just don't like the myth that if perfect people sit and think really hard, perfect software results.
- slavik81 10y agoQt maintained binary compatibility from 4.0 in 2005 to 4.8 in 2011, and has from 5.0 in 2012 to 5.7 in 2016. Providing a stable platform is not some impossible ideal. It's a real thing that GTK's competition provides.