3 ms·
> The authors romanticizing such lifestyles are free to build a cabin in the woods. I don't think the author is saying we should all become hunter gatherers. I
by shkkmo 10y ago
> The authors romanticizing such lifestyles are free to build a cabin in the woods.
I don't think the author is saying we should all become hunter gatherers. I think the author is using those hunter gather cultures as examples of one where a lack of constant work doesn't bring negative consequences.
You are nitpicking the author's (somewhat poorly made) argument, but not making a counter argument of your own.
As far as I can tell, the counter argument runs this way (please correct me if this is not the argument you are trying to make):
1) People need to work to feel purpose and be happy. 2) People will only work if it is necessary in order to feed, clothe and house themselves. 3) Therefor we must make access to food, clothing and housing contingent on work so that people will be happy.
I have several issues with this argument. The first is that 1) and 2) clearly do not apply to everybody, but to some unknown portion of the population. There is little evidence as to what those proportions are, which makes the argument difficult to evaluate effectively.
My second problem with this argument is that the underlying assumption that we should deny people the choice to be purposeless and unhappy. This seems like an very presumptuous and authoritarian premise. To allow people the freedom to pursue happiness necessitates allowing them the freedom to choose unhappiness.