11 ms·
Would a Work-Free World Be So Bad?
- NetTechM 10y agoI'm going to guess that a good portion of the depressed people reportedly unemployed, would list their reason as "Broke". Might explain why there are double the numbers of depressed people in the unemployed vs the employed. Not so much a lack of purpose, but a lack of money. Money might not buy happiness, but its a lot easier to be happy with money than it is without it.
- acr25 10y agoWhy yes, yes it would.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- nurettin 10y ago>20 percent of Americans who have been unemployed for at least a year report having depression Maybe because they have this irrational belief that having no money to pay rent is bad?
- buckbova 10y agoThat's a "duh" moment. I think it'd be more relevant to interview retired persons in reasonably good health.
- squozzer 10y agoAnd finances. Also might be useful to track lottery winners, though i once read a book published 30 years ago that was a bit depressing on the subject.
- Noseshine 10y agoThe problem with winning lots of money is that it is disruptive and usually takes a big toll on friends and family. Which is not the case when you earn the money yourself, because that also comes with a selection process - different kinds of friends, those who themselves grew into or are making enough money.
- daveqr 10y agoChanging the designation from "unemployed" to "retired" raises happiness. Source: Tyler Cowen, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Pk654J8-5c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Pk654J8-5c
- lisper 10y agoIt's not just that. It's also wondering, "What is wrong with me?" when they get rejected again and again with no explanation given because employers are so afraid of discrimination lawsuits.
- buckbova 10y ago> "American towns and cities aren’t really built for lots of free time: Public spaces tend to be small islands in seas of private property, and there aren’t many places without entry fees where adults can meet new people or come up with ways to entertain one another." Unsubstatiated bull. I've hundreds destinations near me with no entrance fees, beaches, trails, clubs, churches, libraries, parks, etc. > The primary purpose of the educational system is to teach people to work. And that's why the curriculum includes civics, american history, geography, literature? K-12 does not perpare students to become workers aside from providing a struture of authority and some discipline.
- ch4s3 10y agoPerhaps you don't live in a typical town. Most small towns don't have beaches, and most have tiny parks. Trails aren't the most common either.
- buckbova 10y agoMost have lake, rivers, or access to an ocean. If not this, they have mountains or other natural features. If you're living in a barren wasteland, I suggest you get outta there! Let's take a typical american city, cleveland ohio. Plenty of trails: http://www.traillink.com/city/cleveland-oh-trails.aspx http://www.traillink.com/city/cleveland-oh-trails.aspx Beaches: http://www.cleveland.com/travel/index.ssf/2015/06/the_10_best_beaches_on_ohios_l.html#0 http://www.cleveland.com/travel/index.ssf/2015/06/the_10_bes... Parks: http://www.clevelandmetroparks.com/Main/Recreation/Hiking-and-Walking-12.aspx http://www.clevelandmetroparks.com/Main/Recreation/Hiking-an...
- Throwaway23412 10y agoWhat makes a typical American city? One could argue that the second largest city in Ohio is not a typical city.
- wdmeldon 10y agoCleveland doesn't have much going for it, but our parks and trails are truly incredible. The Cleveland Metroparks are a definite source of pride for North East Ohio.
- carsongross 10y agoLeaving aside the existential meaning found in non-alienated creative work, if the reproductive fitness of the violent, criminal and sociopathic is not constrained, yes, it will be.
- jrapdx3 10y agoHow is a "work-free world" even possible? There are always problems to solve, who will solve them? Finding and applying solutions is work and one or more people must do it. Getting paid is orthogonal to the effort. Even if performed voluntarily there is still work that needs to be accomplished. Even having fun is a hell of a lot of work in all proportion. It's no mystery, work is the implication of existence.
- ThomPete 10y agoThe idea is that many of those problems can be solved via technology removing the need for most of the people needing to do work in this world.
- jrapdx3 10y agoYes, that's an understandable idea, but constructing and maintaining the technological means to the end requires at least as much work as ever, though it is work of different kinds. Besides technological solutions create new, unanticipated problems that need to be solved. And this endless cycle is inherent in human existence. We regard present technology as far advanced vs. what there was 2000 years ago, yet we have at least as many problems to preoccupy us as there ever were. Everything changes, technologies in particular, except for one thing, and that's human nature. We can't escape the essence of our being.
- sp332 10y agorequires at least as much work as ever It really doesn't. Machines have been putting people out of work for ages. We could survive it for a while by growing the economy pretty fast, but any time it slows down, things get bad. Look at truck driving alone - it's the most common job in most states, and when that gets even partially automated, it's not going to create that many new problems to be "solved".
- randyrand 10y agoYet employment has not changed over the ages.
- TempleOS 10y agoI am CEO of Intel. I have a space alien.
- bko 10y agoAmong the dubious claims that the author provides no back-up for I found this gem: > Plus, in many modern-day societies, unemployment can also be downright boring. American towns and cities aren’t really built for lots of free time: Public spaces tend to be small islands in seas of private property, and there aren’t many places without entry fees where adults can meet new people or come up with ways to entertain one another. Really? I feel the market for entertainment and those interested in niche activities is as rich as it has ever been. > “Sometimes people retire from their work, and they don’t know what to do,” Gray says. “They’ve lost the ability to create their own activities.” It’s a problem that never seems to plague young children. “There are no three-year-olds that are going to be lazy and depressed because they don’t have a structured activity,” he says. I've read the opposite from PG, who suggests that children are now unhappy and depressed because they have no purpose. Many parents are just using schools as daycare [0] > But need it be this way? Work-free societies are more than just a thought experiment—they’ve existed throughout human history. Consider hunter-gatherers, who have no bosses, paychecks, or eight-hour workdays. Ten thousand years ago, all humans were hunter-gatherers, and some still are. The authors romanticizing such lifestyles are free to build a cabin in the woods. But one should understand the accompanying poverty that would accompany such a decision. I could go on... [0] http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html
- dublinben 10y agoHunter-gatherer societies have absolutely nothing to do with 'building a cabin in the woods' or poverty. They represent a highly social period in human development that lasted for tens of thousands of years. It has been argued that we have never been as happy or healthy ever since.[0] [0] http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html http://www.ditext.com/diamond/mistake.html
- wangchow 10y agoJust watch Wall-E and there's the answer. :) Jokes aside: idle hands lead to new art, science, and culture on the one hand; and trouble on the other hand. For those with a natural inclination for creative endeavors they will explore. For people who have desires to conquer, pillage and plunder they'll go around beating people up and destroying things. For the lazy people that like sitting around, they'll end up just like Wall-E predicts.
- slackstation 10y agoA high percentage of unemployed young men roaming the streets of your civilization is a dangerous thing. But, if those young men aren't angry for not having a job and are entertained by things like video games all day. I don't think you'll have much trouble. People might take a generation or two to adapt but, we will adapt. Eventually, doing "nothing" with your life will be socially frowned upon so people will try to find interesting, unique bohemian pursuits if only to appear like an interesting and well rounded person at dinner parties. Men will certainly do this. Without the ability to make lots of money, men will have to have something to attract women. Men have been doing this for literally thousands of generations. It's not going to change any time soon. Also, I see a future where people will work out alot more. It's incredible how cheap and easy lifting something heavy repeatedly decreases stress, makes one more attractive to the opposite sex and makes one happy. In a post scarcity world, I see alot of gyms and not people too fat to get out of their chair. Even without the capital markets or paying rent to spur competition, there will always be the sexual market to spur competition. In a Wall-E world, the one guy who works out would get more women. The woman who worked out would get access to the best men. If both of these groups had nothing but free time, mating market competition alone would lead to an explosion of attractive people. If one was raised not to over-eat or was constantly stressed out from work (in order to survive) then the chances of being obese would drop. People today are fat because they sit all day, get stressed from work. Poor people are stressed because they don't have enough money. Rich people are stressed (maybe less so) because they are competing to get more money. If you have massive unemployment from technology, you won't have the social stigma of not having a job. Or to put it another way, you can surround yourself with people who are jobless and you'll compare yourselves in other ways. We already see this with hipsters. Millennials already are in the first generation of post-Work thinking. They already demand more from a job than just a steady paycheck (often because finding and getting one is so hard). They look for fulfillment, work/life balance and opportunities to change the world for the better. This will only continue and deepen. Despite media that competes for attention by making more and more dire predictions and alarming rhetoric, the world is largely getting better. More diseases are being eradicated, billions are being lifted out of poverty, billions more are gaining access to the entirety of the world's information. There are interesting problems to solve and they will be solved quickly in our lifetimes. It will be extremely pleasing to be a part of the world as we eliminate poverty and bring the global standard of living up to where the poorest of us will still be able to live a decent life. The optimal path could usher in the greatest climb and heights humanity has ever seen. We could make a world better than people 200 years ago could have even imagined. We could potentially make basically Heaven on Earth if we play this right. > Edited for grammar and clarity. It's still a bit rambly
- beatpanda 10y agoThe problem with all if these arguments is that it assumes there's no other work you'd rather be doing aside from whatever work you've been forced to contort your desires into in order to pay rent. I think there's probably a lot of socially valuable work not getting done because social value doesn't translate to economic value.
- theseatoms 10y agoIs that a problem though? Freed from the socio-economic obligation to maximizing income from labor, (due to basic income) one is able to pursue these other types of more p-personally rewarding work.
- CydeWeys 10y agoEver read the Culture series? Yeah, until we achieve that level of technological sophistication, where human labor isn't needed because much more intelligent AIs and robots handle everything, then we can't truly have a work-free world. Don't get me wrong, the hedonistic Culture sounds amazing, it's just so far from reality as it stands today that it's not even worth talking about as anything other than science fiction. Star Trek would be another post-scarcity parallel to draw, and again, it's very far from our current level of progress.
- carsongross 10y agothe hedonistic culture sounds amazing Not to everyone, it doesn't.
- CydeWeys 10y agoWhen you strip out capitalization in my quote like that you completely change the meaning. The Culture is the name of a wide-ranging space-faring civilization in the series of novels by Iain M. Banks. That's what I was referring to. And yes, it's capitalized, same as e.g. "United States".
- shkkmo 10y ago> It's just so far from reality as it stands today that it's not even worth talking about as anything other than science fiction We need to discuss this today, because we need to determine the path we will take forward. 1) Do we impede the adoption of automation to make sure there is work for everyone? 2) Do we have to keep the increasingly large numbers of unemployed mired in poverty to incentivize people to do the remaining necessary work? 3) Do we allow people the economic freedom to choose whether to work or not and then trust that the necessary work will get done because enough people want power and status? I personally think 1) is a bad idea and will retard our progression. However, if you believe work is necessary for happiness and we have a duty to provide happiness for everyone, then 1) seems to be the only choice. (The article's point is to make an argument agains this option) I do think we need a balance between 2) and 3). To me the unknown is how much economic freedom can we provide before we start losing economic output. I don't think we need to have a clear answer for this right now, but we can find the balance gradually by introducing a slowly increasing basic income.
- haroem 10y agothroughout the comments, people have commented about the necessity of work as if the only jobs required for society to function are 40 hour corporate office accounting professionals and IT staff. the entire concept vastly downplays the actual number of services people utilize and purchase. how do you automate a lawsuit? which robot knows how to install a new circuit breaker box? and even if a robot could hypothetically discover new oil fields who decides how it searches and where are these mythological solar powered oil field search bots that have close to unlimited range so nobody has to figure out what depot they're stashed in? finally, how do I build a new computer and phone from scratch when no slave labor exists to create all the components that go into that design since apple and microsoft and samsung and sony all have to go out of business because nobody has any money to buy their devices? I would google it, but they're out of business since ads don't work in a society without money. the library card only goes so far. psychological thrillers to academic psychiatry, kids books to romance novels, newspaper articles going back 50 years, but somehow I don't think I'd be able to learn micro-computing circa 2016. It would be back to concepts circa 1980-1996 and the entire field would be tedious again. yes. a work free world would be terrible. I've thought about it a lot because the better part of my life is spent figuring out how to work less. you notice over time the people who don't have a choice in automation and they get my respect because there's very little chance they're ever unemployed longer than a couple days in their lifetime.
- shkkmo 10y agoI'm not sure what argument you are making, you seem to be missing the point of the article. You seem to be saying a work-free world is not technically feasible without reducing economic output. I think if such a world is possible, it is quite far off and dependent on numerous advances in robotics and AI. However, the article is not trying to say such a world is feasible, but trying to make an argument about whether we should be imparting a value to work besides the economic value that work creates. (I.E. should we value work because it is necessary to provide purpose and happiness).
- slackstation 10y agoIt's not that there would be no work or that there would be no jobs or companies staffed with people. The point is that the average median person might not be good enough to get a job. If automation makes it so that only 20% of people are employed in any traditional sense that we recognize today; that world would be drastically different than the one we have. In that world, we have a path where we don't get rid of money but, just use taxes on large mega companies and redistibute that money as a basic income to people without a job. This keeps capitalism and the efficiencies it brings. With basic income, you still have advertising, you still have companies and you still have consumers buying things. There is still competition to push quality up and prices down. There is still the invisible hand of the market. It's elegant in that it achieves the goals of eliminating both poverty and forced labor to survive without eliminating the competition that makes the world so damned efficient and effective.
- Pica_soO 10y agoYes, but not for the reasons we expect it to be. I think people would find other sources of self-worth and dedication too. The problem is the guys who need people to play the games of power. I don't think that a psychopath actually can exist without his daily dose of personal power and domination gestures. These guys need people to fill there little model trains that race against one another. I think if you would automate the whole factory, up to the CEOs secretary, the market value staying the same, the reward staying the same, the CEO would drop the project like a hot potato- or would start to hire people for useless work. And im okay with that- those guys are better kept from the streets.
- partycoder 10y agoPeople might just work on activities they like (e.g: the maker movement, open source, art).