4 ms·
Also - why do people disallow characters such as ,./:;'"[{]}\|-_=+ in passwords on theirs sites. I can't understand this. I would understand banning non-ascii,
by ajuc 17y ago
Also - why do people disallow characters such as
,./:;'"[{]}\|-_=+ in passwords on theirs sites. I can't understand this. I would understand banning non-ascii, but normal ascii characters should be allowed everywhere.
Now every site allows different subset ot such characters, so every site forces user to have different password to it, if user wants non-alphanumerics in password.
I would like to have 3 passwords - trash password for social sites, etc; better password for e-mail; and good password for important things. It would be managable.
Thanks to arbitrary restrictions I have to remember many more passwords. Which is bad for security.
- nazgulnarsil 17y agopassword advice: come up with a system known only to you that generates passwords based on what sort of site you're one. you can base it on the web address, the company name, general category, whatever. now feed that through your algorithm and you have a unique password for each website you visit. if you forget a password you can re-derive it, since there will only be a handful of possibilities. since you'll certainly have your algorithm memorized you never need to write anything down.
- ableal 17y agoThis is much better advice than the "3 categories of password" the GP mentioned. Actually, 3 categories plus derivation is good ;-) The other day I was glad of that. I bought a game, was asked to create an account, typed in a password at the site; then received a confirmation email with the password in plain text - which probably means they are stored in plain text, not to mention left lying around in mail archives. Just a matter of time until one of those sites gets hacked and their DBs circulated. (P.S. I did write them a polite note suggesting not doing it, and they seem to at least have stopped sending passwords in email; I don't have much hope about their storing hashes. Probably plenty of others less blatant but just as insecure ...)
- ableal 17y ago> why do people disallow characters such as ,./:;'"[{]}\|-_=+ Because there are keyboards other than the U.S. PC keyboard. The one I'm using right now, for instance, has '=' as shift-0. With characters echoed as asterisks, if there is any sort of problem with key mapping, the user will be locked out. And giving up or calling support.
- ajuc 17y agoWouldn't it be a problem only if the same user that created a password with this character that isn't on some keyboard will then use this keyboard? I mean - users will probably use characters that are on their keyboards, or that they know how to generate. Why disallow characters when users choose them on their own?
- ableal 17y agoNo travelling, ever ? "Hi, I'm in this resort in Cancun, and I can't login!"
- pavel_lishin 17y agoThat's a moderately extreme scenario. You're inconveniencing users to prevent some possible but unlikely future inconvenience?
- daleharvey 17y agoits not really "extreme", it might be a euro bias but I have had this happen to me a lot, hell getting @ working on some keyboard can be annoying enough.
- BearOfNH 17y agoSo ... don't create passwords with '@' in them?
- theycallmemorty 17y agoAnywhere that uses the same password for their phone system as their website is limited to alphanumeric because you can't type ,./:;'"[{]}\|-_=+ on the phone.
- marcinw 17y agoOne of the mitigations to this is to create a PIN that's unique to a telephone number you've associated with your account.