3 ms·
Ask HN: Is Anyone Cloning the Raspberry Pi Zero?
Like so many people, I've had difficulty obtaining a Raspberry Pi Zero. (Got one finally, thanks, Pi Hut!) It's an open source design, right? Isn't it easier to do a hardware startup these days, especially with no R&D required? Why isn't someone making a killing by cloning the Zero?
- schappim 10y ago>> Why isn't someone making a killing by cloning the Zero? Because at $5 it's not profitable. My company sells ~25-30% of the Raspberry Pis in Australia. When we spoke to the manufacturer for our region they said they weren't looking at manufacturing the Pi Zero V1.3 due to the economics. Their inventory of the Pi Zero has also dried up (as they focused on the RPI 3 Model B). When they did sell the the Pi Zero they sold it as a kit with marked up micro HDMI and USB adaptors. As @mmosta pointed out, the Raspberry Pi is heavily subsidised by sweetheart deals from their manufacturers and component vendors. This is all ok: The point of the Pi is to make computing accessible at a low price, not to make money. It will be interesting to see how the ecosystem as a whole plays out. It's hard to tell. I haven't seen an unsubsidised/non-VC company put out a "cheap" single board computer. The Pi Zero's closest competition (https://getchip.com/pages/chip https://getchip.com/pages/chip) has had a round and I suspect is getting a nice deal from All Winner too!
- tomcam 10y agoThanks for a fascinating and very informative reply. Answers so many questions.
- GFK_of_xmaspast 10y agoWhy do you think that a hardware startup would do a better job of ramping up production than the Pi people do now?
- tomcam 10y agoWhere did I say that?
- grizzles 10y agoMost businesses try to make a profit. In business, competing against a high volume very low margin incumbent is pretty much #1 on the list of things you should never ever do.
- tomcam 10y agoMan, ain't that the truth. Any BOM I try to come up with doesn't get remotely close to the Pi Zero's list price, but I don't know Shenzhen well enough to understand if they could make it happen in quantities of, say, 10,000. But I'm not a hardware guy.
- TomWhitwell 10y agoI don't think that Raspberry Pi is open source hardware at all - the schematics are public, the documentation is open, but I don't think the PCB designs are.
- tomcam 10y agoD'oh! Without access to the PCB designs it would be completely asinine even to consider such a venture. Thanks.
- mmosta 10y agoIt really boils down to the deal the foundation has with Broadcom, even if you could source the chip you would never be able to beat their unit price. The "openness" is rather limited too, there are all manner of NDAs and minimal order quantities associated with the parts in the BOM, nor are the gerbers available. A real pain point for the bleeding-heart OSHW types.
- tomcam 10y agoWell you just answered about 15 nagging questions I had. Thank you.