4 ms·
What are the actionable insights that have come out of fMRI studies? Even when properly conducted (no false positives), the conclusions that are often drawn hav
by hammock 10y ago
What are the actionable insights that have come out of fMRI studies? Even when properly conducted (no false positives), the conclusions that are often drawn have always felt dubious to me. Basically you are looking for regions of the brain that light up with various stimuli. Except that's as far as it goes, we don't yet understand much beyond that.
It's as if you figure out that your car is making a funny sound, and you can pinpoint where it is coming from, you can even reproduce the sound on demand - but you have no idea WHY it sounds the way it does.
- Tomte 10y agoI was participant in a study in linguistics [1] that compared native Polish and native German speakers who were put into an fRMI and played speech sounds. Both Polish and German ones. It clearly showed that speech sounds from your native language are processed in a different part of the brain than non-native speech sounds. Yes, that does not explain much. But it leads towards all kinds of questions. And I found that fascinating. [1] Silvia Lipski, Neurosci Lett. 2007 Mar 19, „A Magnetoencephalographic study on auditory processing of native and nonnative fricative contrasts in Polish and German listeners.“
- shmel 10y agoA small correction: cited study used MEG, not fMRI, as modality. The conclusion itself doesn't look very surprising for me. We already know that the sound processing in general is the same in both hemispheres while the speech processing is very lateralized. From the continuity I could say that there should be a border where speech-like sounds sound like speech and therefore they are processed differently between hemispheres. This study seems to estimate this border.
- Tomte 10y agoThanks for the correction! I misremembered because my professor's group did a lot of fMRI stuff, as well, and in the seminars we mostly talked about those. Speech/language and brain is fascinating. There are resident linguists at major hospitals who are consulted before neurosurgery. Speech sounds are processed faster than other sounds in our brain. Rearranging sentences from active voice to passive voice, silently in your head, lead to easily seen activity in fMRIs, distinct from non-linguistic mental actions. And so on.
- lostlogin 10y agoWhen your about to dig a chunk of someone's brain out and have a variety of routes to get to the offending region, it's handy to know what you might be able to avoid knocking off.