3 ms·
There's free will as in a decision-making system that generates different options and selects one based on constraints, which is something a computer can do, an
by threatofrain 10y ago
There's free will as in a decision-making system that generates different options and selects one based on constraints, which is something a computer can do, and then there's free will as in the ability to defy the mechanics of one's biophysics, which is just an indirect way of saying metaphysical soul.
I don't think empiricists can even discuss the kind of free will which defies causal explanation, the kind of mind which exists outside of the brain.
If you reject that kind of metaphysical soul from the discussion, what remains is whatever soul can be housed in a cage of biophysics. And whether you believe there is fundamental randomness in the universe, or whether given perfect information the universe becomes predictable, both perspectives are equally hostile to the kind of free will people dream about.
People who talk about free will want to escape biophysics, and the only way is to talk about the mind outside the brain, or the ghost outside the machine.
- Retra 10y agoFree will is just the sensation of having a brain that models counterfactuals. It allows you to have emotions like hope and regret, since you are capable of imagining the world being different from how it is. It allows you to understand your role in the consequence-that-is-the-current-reality. And here there's nothing to debate. Of course free will exists. It exists just like every other aspect of mental perspective exists. Nobody is debating whether love, hunger, confusion, or boredom exist just because they aren't quantified and modeled in a properly predictable manner. They're debating free will because religious people want a common experience and a long history of unaddressed confusion to leverage for their self-comfort. A "mystery" that not even scientists can touch.
- neoeldex 10y agoI don't think there's such a thing as a metaphysical soul. What would that look like anyhow? But I do think any sufficient complex system could show patterns which could be perceived as random. Although they may be hard to reason about. I believe consciousness arises from such processes, and the perception of free will.