3 ms·
> I don't see how current [copyright law?] is hampering arts and science, really. Seriously? As one example, people who go to prestigious universities with bi
by jacobolus 17y ago
> I don't see how current [copyright law?] is hampering arts and science, really.
Seriously?
As one example, people who go to prestigious universities with big libraries can get access to all of the scientific output in the world, while others, especially in places without good public libraries, can't get access to that material. If copyright was a more reasonable term, all of that material older than some date could be digitized and widely distributed. This couldn't but help science.
As another, a large portion of the current amateur cultural output (youtube videos, covers of songs, &c.) is currently illegal. But this illegality is out-of-sync with common understandings of the legitimacy of various uses.
It's absurd to justify people's grandchildren (or unrelated people or corporations who bought the rights sometime) collecting royalties for the creative output of 70 years ago with the argument that the original creation wouldn't have happened without such "incentive".
* * *
As for constitutionality, this is a matter which properly belongs to the legislature IMO, not the courts. I just wish our legislators were a bit less beholden to Disney & friends.
- ErrantX 17y agoYou've got me on the first one... The second doesn't necessarily seem to be hampering the arts and science (unless, I suppose, we are saying it hampers access to the arts - which I might agree with).