3 ms·
Funny to use the word "funny" in relation to other people's suffering.
by mikeash 10y ago
Funny to use the word "funny" in relation to other people's suffering.
- moptar 10y agoPerhaps the world would be a less violent place if we laughed at soldiers for their failures instead of glorifying them. The article fittingly ends with "all that suffering .. for what?" It really was a lot of murderous people getting themselves killed and injured while trying to kill other people. Not something to have sympathy for. Sure, they might have been fooled by naive ideas of nationalism, but that's still a problem today - people who are so patriotic they'll kill others and risk their lives for no real reason other than "my country is better than yours"
- mikeash 10y agoSoldiers don't generally start wars. They go where they're told and fight who they're told. The penalties for disobedience are severe. To force someone to fight and then laugh at them for the effects it has on them strikes me as psychopathic.
- Gustomaximus 10y agoMany soldiers are volunteers. You're clearly trying to present one side of an arguement only. Any while I dont believe soldiers suffering is funny, I do feel some nations hero worship soldiers ad nauseum. And further even with severe punishments for people refusing conscription cases, I admire a man like Ali who went to prison over his conviction not to go to war, over someone willing to support a killing machine that they dont believe in because of a few years in gaol. We almost always have a choice. Also I appreciate someone in this (or any) discussion presenting an alternate view. And I like to think HN will remain a place where we can have open minded discussion without pushing clearly limited consideration retorts.
- mikeash 10y agoI wasn't referring to the draft. Everything I said applies to volunteers too. Soldiers don't get the right to disobey orders just because they volunteer. There's a huge gulf between acknowledging the pain and suffering of the veteran, and glorifying soldiers. Totally different concepts.
- saretired 10y agoThe great majority of WW I troops were drafted. Moralizing from a base of total ignorance doesn't advance a cause.
- angry_octet 10y agoI salute your trolling and utter ignorance. WWI history is replete with stories of how pointless it was, hence 'war to end all wars' etc. Overwhelmingly it was the generals and admirals who were happy to throw men into the meat grinder. Haig, Churchill, Ludendorff, they are the monsters.
- moptar 10y agoAbout half of UK WWI soldiers were volunteers. They threw themselves into the meat grinder. Even conscripted people could appeal for being a conscientious objector. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recruitment_to_the_British_Army_during_the_First_World_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Recruitment_to_the_British_Arm...
- andrewchambers 10y agoYou are right, it isn't so funny that people would equate being bullied with having your brain literally scrambled by explosive concussion.
- mikeash 10y agoBecause they know it involves physical brain trauma and still say they have it? Maybe we should be sympathetic to all suffering, rather than criticizing people for not being totally abreast of the latest developments in neuroscience. They're just saying "I hurt," not "I am just as damaged as a veteran at the receiving end of an artillery barrage."
- andrewchambers 10y ago> They're just saying "I hurt," not "I am just as damaged as a veteran at the receiving end of an artillery barrage." No, that is literally what they are saying.
- mikeash 10y agoLiterally, as in those exact words? I'm going to have to ask for a source on that.
- andrewchambers 10y agoYou got me, i can't find that that literal quote (though im pretty sure it exists). I meant to say that is what is intentionally implied.
- mikeash 10y agoI'm going to have to ask for a source on that as well.
- ams6110 10y agoPeople have literally used "PTSD" to refer to both the aftereffects of bullying and wartime combat.