3 ms·
The race of the people speaking it. I'll probably get downvoted for posting that. But I don't see how this essay supports any notion that AAVE is simpler than
by snowwrestler 10y ago
The race of the people speaking it.
I'll probably get downvoted for posting that. But I don't see how this essay supports any notion that AAVE is simpler than standard English, and coldtea doesn't supply any alternative source to support the claim.
Is calling it "simpler" a rigorous statment of some measurable quantity? If so, which one?
Or is it a way to impose a value judgment on the dialect and the people who created it and speak it today?
There is certainly a giant pile of American cultural precedent for the latter.
- intopieces 10y agoThis is a concept called "dialect prestige." AAVE and southern US dialects are "low prestige," despite the fact that among it speakers are plenty of individuals who themselves exhibit "high prestige" characteristics. I venture to say that, given his experiece as a community organizer in Chicago as well as his biracial composition, President Obama is likely a fluent speaker of AAVE and he's got just about the most prestigious job there is. If you need any more evidence of this dynamic, recall Harry Reid before the '08 Election. He characterized Obama as a ‘light-skinned’ African-American ‘with no Negro dialect, unless he wanted to have one.’
- omonra 10y agoHow would Obama know how to speak aave when he grew up in a white family and, from what I understand, didn't socialize much with black people (at least only dated white women) until his mid 20s?
- coldtea 10y ago>But I don't see how this essay supports any notion that AAVE is simpler than standard English, and coldtea doesn't supply any alternative source to support the claim. Do you really need sources to tell you that a subgroup's language is poorer than a mainstream language with a many times its history, speakers, artifacts and literary works? >Or is it a way to impose a value judgment on the dialect and the people who created it and speak it today? No, it's a value judgement on the people who enslaved them and deprived them of opportunities for education and participation in the mainstream culture and language for centuries. And who continue to oppress them through faux-progressive, but essentially condescending, praise for their make-shift language they were forced to come up with.
- tptacek 10y agoThe idiosyncrasies of AAVE can be --- and in this essay are --- plotted against those of many other dialects of English, and, generalized, against even more of the world's great languages. Here again you dismiss it as "makeshift" and its study as "faux-progressive". But whatever it is you think about the dialect, it exists. Millions of people speak it. It is no stranger or less comprehensible than other English dialects whose existence we somehow manage to accept without moral judgement. Perhaps you, like several other commenters on this thread, believe the point of the essay is that AAVE should be nurtured, or even spread to students not acquainted with it. Nobody is making that argument. The closest the essay comes to a moral judgement about AAVE is in pointing out that if AAVE-aware educational strategies produce better outcomes for learning Standard English, our ignorance and prejudice shouldn't prevent use from creating those outcomes. But most of the essay is spent making fun of people who feel they understand AAVE well enough to dismiss it. It's a funny piece, by an universally respected authority. You should read it again with an open mind!
- mitchty 10y agoFun fact though, a lot of Black english originates from Scotland and Ireland linguistically. It isn't simpler, its preserving traits of English dialects not normally heard in America. It has a lot of linguistic traits of those dialects. Which would make sense if the Irish and Scottish slaves taught them their english. I don't think that makes it "simple", that is a judgement I think is invalid and ignores the reality of the dialect.