3 ms·
man, K-12 is no more. K-16 is the bare minimum to function in the current civilization. Obviously this new reality should be reflected in school organization, i
by trhway 10y ago
man, K-12 is no more. K-16 is the bare minimum to function in the current civilization. Obviously this new reality should be reflected in school organization, i.e. whole K-16 should be covered by the public.
- ams6110 10y agoIronically 1-8 used to be the minumum and those 8th graders were probably better prepared for life than today's 12th graders are.
- taneq 10y agoBy which you mean, life was navigable by an 8th grader back then? I don't think the quality of year 8 students has dropped that significantly.
- douche 10y agoHow much value is added during 9-12th grade? A k-8 program with a little bit of life skills and shop would be better than what I did in 12 years. Especially if you consider that people were working sub-minimum wage jobs for a few years after getting through 8th grade in those days, which were effectively apprenticeships.
- darpa_escapee 10y agoI'd find it hard to navigate life competently without learning geometry, algebra and trigonometry. Calculus as well. Painting a room, taking out a loan and (in ways) driving a car all incorporate those skills. You can do each task without any knowledge of those math subjects, but you can reason about them much better with a solid understanding of the fundamentals.
- douche 10y agoI wouldn't bet on that. I've known too many carpenters and general contractors who flunked out well before calculus. Now, they may figure stuff out the hard way, working off approximations and rules of thumb, but they figure it out, and do the hard work, too.
- darpa_escapee 10y agoHow do you determine how much paint you'd need to paint a wall without basic geometry? How about figuring out what angles and lengths to cut materials? If you can't physically measure a side of wall/house/etc you're going to have to use algebra, trig and/or geometry to figure out the lengths.
- ori_b 10y agoSurely, you're joking. > How do you determine how much paint you'd need to paint a wall without basic geometry? You guess, and if you're short, you buy more. If you're over, you use it on the next job of throw it out. > How about figuring out what angles and lengths to cut materials? There are lots of methods. You can lay it out and mark it on the ground before making cuts. You can build forms and templates out of scrap or cardboard via eyeballing and adjustment. Math can save some time, but you can usually get by without it.
- ori_b 10y agoSurely, you're joking. > How do you determine how much paint you'd need to paint a wall without basic geometry? You guess, and if you're short, you buy more. If you're over, you use it on the next job of throw it out. > How about figuring out what angles and lengths to cut materials? There are lots of methods. You can lay it out and mark it on the ground before making cuts. You can build forms and templates out of scrap or cardboard via eyeballing and adjustment.
- jerf 10y agoIn which case the "bare minimum" signaling will just move up to the next level, and then graduate degrees will be required. At which point post-graduate will be required. You can't signal that you're above average if everybody comes up to the same "above average" at the same time. This isn't even hypothetical, there are already industries where this is how it works. A 4-year-degree in teaching or social work just gets you in the door; you are very much expected to keep going and get masters degrees if you want any sort of raise. (It is not clear to me how this makes anyone a better teacher or social worker. It is credentialism in a pure form.) Combined with the general drop in signaling quality of a 4-year-degree as the curricula get easier, this is the inevitable outcome. We don't need to pour even more money into funding people's walking on the treadmill, we need to attack the reason why the treadmill is necessary in the first place.
- douche 10y agoWhoo, boy, is master's level coursework in teaching a layup...
- trhway 10y ago>In which case the "bare minimum" signaling will just move up to the next level, and then graduate degrees will be required. At which point post-graduate will be required. definitely. In the future where all "simple" jobs are automated the basic necessary skill level would be an ability to do research, ie. the post-graduate level. Without it, one would be able only to enjoy the life provided by the automated systems and wouldn't be able to contribute to the society. It has already happened several times for previous levels of education - from reading/writing as a sign of being "educated" hundreds years ago to manufacturing jobs (K-12 level) which were middle-class jobs just a few decades ago. >A 4-year-degree in teaching or social work just gets you in the door; you are very much expected to keep going and get masters degrees if you want any sort of raise. these are government jobs, not subject to market forces, it is more like armed forces in that regard.
- virmundi 10y agoNope, social work is not just government jobs. My wife is a social worker at a hospice (not government). She had to have her masters to get the job. The next thing she has to get is a clinical license. Fun fact, that's a paying internship. She pays a mentor for 2 years to watch her do her job. After the monitoring, my wife is eligible to take a test. If she passes that test, she gets the license. That licenses enables her to increase her odds of getting a social work job in a hospital or government job like the VA, which is not just hospitals. When all of this is said and done, she had her undergrad (fortunately paid for by her mother's employer, the school), which cost about 100k. Then we paid for her 30k masters. Now we'll pay 2-4k depending on the license mentor. So 132k for a job that pays...wait for it... at best 60k a year! Compare this to my BS in CS which opened at 42k and now is somewhere around 120k. Yay idiotic higher ed inflation. As an interesting side note, most of this stupidity is caused by the social workers themselves. Like Rodney Dangerfield, they felt like they got no respect from the doctors, legislators and nurses. So they actually pushed for laws around mandated education! They pushed for licenses. They pushed for licenses that could only be obtained with job experience! You couldn't get experience to get the license to get the job that would get you the experience! We actually fled Indiana because of it. Florida is more reasonable.