3 ms·
This is one of the most elitist comments I've read on HN. What are your special qualifications that allow you to say who is and who is not qualified to comment
by bogomipz 10y ago
This is one of the most elitist comments I've read on HN.
What are your special qualifications that allow you to say who is and who is not qualified to comment on a topical issue?
I'm guessing by your comment stating that he is a skilled musician that you aren't actually familiar with Brian Eno at all. He's an unskilled musician, that's by his own admission. He's not technically proficient on any instrument. He's quite the technologist though.
- dredmorbius 10y agoSpace alien cats don't need qualifications. Nor do they claim them. As others have noted, Eno's piece is a poor rewrite of I Pencil, itself a poorly reasoned propaganda piece. Crooked Timber has an excellent deconstruction of that: http://crookedtimber.org/2011/04/16/i-pencil-a-product-of-the-mixed-economy/ http://crookedtimber.org/2011/04/16/i-pencil-a-product-of-th... The one at Freakonomics is weaker sauce but also pretty biting: http://freakonomics.com/podcast/i-pencil/ http://freakonomics.com/podcast/i-pencil/ I've pointed to several sources discussing technological unemployment, and more critically the long history of discussion of that topic from 1800 forward in mainstream and heterodox economic, as well as political and other literature. None of which Eno's careless handwave points at. If informed, sourced, intelligent, and specifically refutable comment is elitist, I'll take it. You've also focused on the irrelevant element of my argument, though if anything, you're also undercutting your own criticism of me. Eno's skill is evident in his body of work. Which I have listened to, own some of, and rather like. His self-description is at best inaccurate. Your assumptions as to my familiarity or otherwise with Eno's works place you on the rather precarious precipice of a domain in which I am and insist privileged expertise of obvious nature. Cheers.
- bogomipz 10y ago"Your assumptions as to my familiarity or otherwise with Eno's works place you on the rather precarious precipice of a domain in which I am and insist privileged expertise of obvious nature." That is one poorly formed run-on sentence. What does that even mean? That's sounds as though it came out of a babble generator. Is that an AI joke? "You've also focused on the irrelevant element of my argument, though if anything, you're also undercutting your own criticism of me." Really? So your inaccuracy is irrelevant? How convenient for you. And no I've not focused on that, I focused on elitism and now some strange sense of entitlement you seem to reserve for yourself. Sorry I don't give a toss about your brand of pop-econmics? You should get over yourself. I am not alone in this view either: "We and others have noted a discouraging tendency in the Freakonomics body of work to present speculative or even erroneous claims with an air of certainty." Source: http://www.americanscientist.org/issues/pub/freakonomics-what-went-wrong http://www.americanscientist.org/issues/pub/freakonomics-wha... The fact that you're all bent out of shape over content on the Edge and yet you support your infallibility by citing a pop entertainment show on NPR is kind of laughable.
- dredmorbius 10y agoIt means I know my life, my experiences, my tastes, and my thoughts, far better than you. Don't even try to claim primacy of such knowledge. Not of me, not of anyone. (Now, if someone's saying one thing and doing another, point that out. But a person owns and has priviledged access to what rattles within their own skull.) The economics I cited and referenced is most decidedly not pop. I've got my own thoughts on some matters, those aren't what I'm presenting here. You're also now going all ad-hom on Freakonomics. I didn't say that Freakonomics is right. I'm presenting it as a valid argument, in place of constructing a similar one from whole sauce for your entertainment. The point isn't that either source are authorities, but that I've read and agree with the reasoning. And just hang onto that cloth you're about to hand me, I've little need of it.