4 ms·
How come Tesla has to answer for human failure?
by ricardobeat 10y ago
How come Tesla has to answer for human failure?
- benkarst 10y agoTesla calls the technology "Autopilot". What does that mean to you?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- diggan 10y agoIt depends on what kind of failure. If there is a red button next to an slightly darker red button and you get the instruction from your boss to press the red one, you have a 50% of failing. But maybe the designer of said buttons should have thought about giving the buttons different colors instead of similar ones. "The Design of Everyday Things" talks about this, that sometimes it's the designer of something's fault, rather than the user of the something. Also called "Human Error" by statements. Search for "https://archive.org/stream/DesignOfEverydayThings/DesignOfEverydayThings_djvu.txt" https://archive.org/stream/DesignOfEverydayThings/DesignOfEv... here https://archive.org/stream/DesignOfEverydayThings/DesignOfEverydayThings_djvu.txt https://archive.org/stream/DesignOfEverydayThings/DesignOfEv... Point being, unless Tesla makes it safe to be used as autopilot, you probably shouldn't say it's autopilot. Otherwise it's not good enough and you would fault Tesla for the design rather than the users of the autopilot.
- ricardobeat 10y agoI agree that the naming is poor - that doesn't make them liable for human error though, the driver has to opt in and is made well aware of the operation modes. Incidentally I'm carrying that exact book in my backpack right now. I think the problem here is much deeper, and even opposite to what Norman discusses in the book. An autopilot is the epitome of "don't make me think" - I want to go from A to B, no need to worry about the driving. The problem at hand is that the technology is not mature enough to fully take over from humans, and we are not good at staying alert in this half-focused state - I don't own a Tesla but it must be incredibly boring. It's an interesting conflict of tech vs human nature.
- synpatcal 10y agoThis is a easily repeatable failure. Camera looks up from bumper, see a overhead sign, continues on. Later it looks up from the bumper, and a trailer is down about the same area, continues on. Nope... Need radar. Give me a break.