3 ms·
I guess where I get into the problem is the wording specifically mentions "exclusive right", but none of the wording says "public interest". Progress is good f
by protomyth 17y ago
I guess where I get into the problem is the wording specifically mentions "exclusive right", but none of the wording says "public interest". Progress is good for the public, but it isn't a 1-to-1 correspondence with "public interest". Also, it mentions this exclusive right as the solution, not a suggestion of one possible solution.
- inerte 17y agoBecause everything done by a government should be for the public interest, even if one person or a small group is directly benefited. I'm not a US Constitution specialist, heck, I am from Brazil. But that's usually how things are: You don't exactly need to keep saying "_this_ is for the public interest", because _everything_ should be.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI think you've got it backwards. The government wouldn't have the right to just create monopolies for no reason. This allows them to set up such monopolies as long as they serve a specific purpose. So not "you need to promote progress, so set up monopolies" but "you can set up monopolies, but only to promote progress". That's why it specifically mentions "exclusive rights" because that's the contentious bit.
- protomyth 17y agoThe creation of a temporary monopoly allows the person who produced the work time to make a living off it, thus encouraging other people to do the same. The monopoly isn't for "no reason", it has a very specific purpose.