2 ms·
The article cites the opinion of several other scientists. For example: "To be clear, the hypothesis that global warming is destabilizing the polar jet stream
by greenyoda 10y ago
The article cites the opinion of several other scientists. For example:
"To be clear, the hypothesis that global warming is destabilizing the polar jet stream is a legitimate idea that has been published in peer-reviewed journals, though it remains controversial. But even the scientist who developed the hypothesis, Jennifer Francis, a professor of meteorology at Rutgers University, suggested it had been misapplied by Scribbler and Beckwith. “I’d say cross-equator flow cannot be unprecedented, maybe not even all that unusual,” she said."
Francis hardly sounds like someone who doesn't believe in climate change (since her research is about how global warming destabilizes the jet stream).
Also, neither of the two people who made the claims are established climate scientists - they're a writer and a PhD student:
"The two bloggers who have perpetuated this misinformation are Robert Scribbler, who describes himself as ” a progressive novelist, non-fiction writer and emerging threats expert,” and Paul Beckwith, who is working on a PhD with “a focus on abrupt climate system change” at the University of Ottawa."
If this was really an unprecedented event that signified a threat, why didn't any of the thousands of climate scientists notice it? If it was really a significant result, wouldn't the PhD student (and his advisor) have tried to get it published in the peer reviewed literature before going public with it on a blog (a publication medium which has no value to an academic researcher's career)?