3 ms·
My basic problem is reconciling "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right
by protomyth 17y ago
My basic problem is reconciling "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts, by securing for limited Times to Authors and Inventors the exclusive Right to their respective Writings and Discoveries." with "General Principle 2 repeats the common error that copyright should balance the public interest with 'protecting and rewarding the author'. This error interferes with proper judgment of any copyright policy question, since that should be based on the public interest."
- ggchappell 17y agoI don't think there is a problem there. Look at the first statement you quoted. It explains why (to promote ...) and then it explains what is to be done (securing for limited times ...). Protecting and rewarding authors may be a result of the "securing" part, but it is not listed as a motivation for it.
- dasht 17y agoA reasonable question. They are reconciled by narrowly observing that the clause "To promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts" describes a specific public interest. You can also narrowly observe that there is no specific enumeration of what comprises an "exclusive Right". Stallman also (used to?) advocate for "media taxes" and to paraphrase that idea and draw it to its conclusion for the contemporary environment: This would be something like a tax on IP traffic, an enforceable right of verifiable authentication, and a disbursing of those tax revenues to popular Authors and Inventors based on some formula settled by Congress. Such would be radically different from what we have. It would not preclude the freedom to share. It would be consistent with the Constitutional mandate if it genuinely encouraged Authors and Inventors to publish. It would be especially attentive to the purpose ("To promote...") of the regulatory power ("limited Times ... exclusive Right"). Beyond the narrow readings, you can look at (for example) the correspondence between Jefferson and Hamilton and its historic legislative and jurisprudence context. Exclusivity of publication was only grudgingly added to the powers of Congress. It was added in part because of a historic pattern of several of the Colonies to establish a state-run monopoly on printing. It was added in part because of a then more current familiarity with the early economics of print and the role of patronage in inventing. The early US copyright and patent laws make far less sense, given how they were argued for, in the current technological climate. Substitutes - even radical substitutes like a "media tax" - would seem to better fit the goals the founders were trying to achieve (if we can judge that by their own writings).
- protomyth 17y agoI guess where I get into the problem is the wording specifically mentions "exclusive right", but none of the wording says "public interest". Progress is good for the public, but it isn't a 1-to-1 correspondence with "public interest". Also, it mentions this exclusive right as the solution, not a suggestion of one possible solution.
- inerte 17y agoBecause everything done by a government should be for the public interest, even if one person or a small group is directly benefited. I'm not a US Constitution specialist, heck, I am from Brazil. But that's usually how things are: You don't exactly need to keep saying "_this_ is for the public interest", because _everything_ should be.
- ZeroGravitas 17y agoI think you've got it backwards. The government wouldn't have the right to just create monopolies for no reason. This allows them to set up such monopolies as long as they serve a specific purpose. So not "you need to promote progress, so set up monopolies" but "you can set up monopolies, but only to promote progress". That's why it specifically mentions "exclusive rights" because that's the contentious bit.
- protomyth 17y agoThe creation of a temporary monopoly allows the person who produced the work time to make a living off it, thus encouraging other people to do the same. The monopoly isn't for "no reason", it has a very specific purpose.
- gjm11 17y agoStallman's written on that before; see http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/misinterpreting-copyright.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/misinterpreting-copyright.html . His position (which, for what it's worth, seems correct to me) is that I.8 of the US constitution says that the purpose of copyright is simply "to promote the progress of science and useful arts", and sees "protecting and rewarding the author" as a means to that end, not as something to be balanced against it. (Note also that the Constitution doesn't say that there must or should be copyright; only that Congress is permitted, for the specific purpose mentioned, to establish copyright.) If it turned out that copyright actually works against "the progress of science and useful arts", a believer in "balancing" might think it should stay anyway, to protect and reward authors. Stallman would not, and the US Constitution does seem to be on his side. (I am not claiming, and I don't know whether Stallman would, that copyright laws that can be shown to impede the progress of science and useful arts would actually be unconstitutional.)
- ErrantX 17y agoI am not claiming, and I don't know whether Stallman would, that copyright laws that can be shown to impede the progress of science and useful arts would actually be unconstitutional This is my issue with that entire point. I don't see how current is hampering arts and science, really. Which is a problem because people can turn around and say so; which works to invalidate the argument. It's a key point because it's what we need to consider when revising copyright law properly; but for dismantling the current law it doesn't seem, currently, a strong argument.
- jacobolus 17y ago> I don't see how current [copyright law?] is hampering arts and science, really. Seriously? As one example, people who go to prestigious universities with big libraries can get access to all of the scientific output in the world, while others, especially in places without good public libraries, can't get access to that material. If copyright was a more reasonable term, all of that material older than some date could be digitized and widely distributed. This couldn't but help science. As another, a large portion of the current amateur cultural output (youtube videos, covers of songs, &c.) is currently illegal. But this illegality is out-of-sync with common understandings of the legitimacy of various uses. It's absurd to justify people's grandchildren (or unrelated people or corporations who bought the rights sometime) collecting royalties for the creative output of 70 years ago with the argument that the original creation wouldn't have happened without such "incentive". * * * As for constitutionality, this is a matter which properly belongs to the legislature IMO, not the courts. I just wish our legislators were a bit less beholden to Disney & friends.