3 ms·
You do realize that the death of Mao, the cleansing of th Gang of Four, and the end of the Cultural Revolution was only 40 years ago? A significant fraction of
by mcguire 10y ago
You do realize that the death of Mao, the cleansing of th Gang of Four, and the end of the Cultural Revolution was only 40 years ago? A significant fraction of people there survived the Great Leap Forward and now live in a weirdly capitalistic country. Couple that with the difference between rural and urban China, and I expect you might want to forgive the author abit of dislocation.
- coldtea 10y ago>You do realize that the death of Mao, the cleansing of the Gang of Four, and the end of the Cultural Revolution was only 40 years ago? A significant fraction of people there survived the Great Leap Forward and now live in a weirdly capitalistic country. I do realize that -- in fact it's not that different from what's been going on elsewhere, e.g. where I live. A lot of European countries had a similar story (WWII was 70 years ago, fascist regimes/Juntas in Grece, Portugal and Spain ended like 40 years ago or less, the Eastern bloc collapsed 26 years ago. Romanians that are 40 year old now grew up with Ceausescu and several whole countries didn't exist but as part of Yugoslavia or Czechoslovakia. The didn't jump (no pun intended) from the Great Leap Forward into a weirdly capitalistic country overnight -- this has been going on since the 80s. The author himself was 17 years old when the cultural revolution ended -- he spent most of his life in the transition, not in that era. Plus all of his "unreal" examples (from restaurants re-using cooking oil, to corrupt higher-ups, to the polygamist official, etc could have happened just as well in 1970 or in 1850 China -- or anywhere else for that matter). He might have a point -- but not based on his examples. They sound more like a lack of experience with similar things going on in most countries ("it can only happen here") than genuine unreal-ness.