11 ms·
A fascinating little beastie that loves prime numbers
- scott_s 17y agoA prime numbered cycle means that the cicada rarely meets a predator (since any predator would have to be synchronized to 17 years, for example) and mass emergence would overwhelm any predator around. I think that's half accurate. They meet many, many predators - hence the great numbers overwhelming predators, as you point out. Their numbers are so great that all existing predators can gorge themselves, and there's still plenty left to mate. Rather, their prime-number periodicity reduces the likelihood that a specialized predator will evolve. Many predators eat them, but none of those predators have evolved to specifically eat those cicadas.
- btilly 17y agoSorry, but you are wrong. Generalized predators tend to have boom/bust cycles that are a small integer number of years. When the boom aligns with the cicadas, it sucks for the cicadas. When the bust aligns with the cicadas, it is great for them. Having a non-prime period would synchronize that boom/bust cycle with the cicada's cycle, and would make every generation a bad one for the cicada's strategy. Eventually this would make the cicadas go extinct. There is no possibility of a specialized predator evolving because said predator would spend most of the time starving.
- scott_s 17y agoThere is no possibility of a specialized predator evolving because said predator would spend most of the time starving. A specialized predator could evolve to have the same cycle as the cicadas. Which is the point of the theory for why the cicadas have a prime-number cycle: it decreases the chance that a predator species will happen-upon a cycle that only sometimes aligns with the cicadas. The cicadas themselves are so numerous that no general predator species will have anything close to a chance to hunt all of them.
- camccann 17y agoAlso significant is that cicadas, while numerous, aren't very large. Predator body size tends to be roughly proportional to their prey's body size, and larger animals tend to live longer. The net result is that the cicada cycle is a bit longer than the expected lifespan of a hypothetical predator, making it even harder for such to evolve.
- itistoday 17y agoA prime numbered cycle means that the cicada rarely meets a predator (since any predator would have to be synchronized to 17 years, for example) and mass emergence would overwhelm any predator around. I don't understand. That sentence doesn't explain why it can't be a non-prime number like every 16 years, or every 18 years. It looks like part of the argument is missing.
- itistoday 17y agoAh OK, the full explanation is in the linked paper: The present work is based on the hypothesis that the cycle length is a prime number in order to optimally escape predators. For example, a prey with a 12-year cycle will meet—every time it appears—properly synchronized preda- tors appearing every 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 or 12 years, whereas a mutant with a 13-year period has the advantage of being subject to fewer predators. So it has to do with the number of available (different) predators, because their populations also go through cycles. Link: http://www.cims.nyu.edu/~eve2/predprey.pdf http://www.cims.nyu.edu/~eve2/predprey.pdf
- jgrahamc 17y agoWell suppose it's not a prime number then if you have some predator whose cycle is a factor of the cicada cycle then it's going to meet up with the cicada every time. Suppose you have an 18 year cicada, it has factor of 2, 3, 6, 9 so any predator that peaks every 2, 3, 6 or 9 years can synchronize with the cicada and be around to eat it. But if the cicada has a prime numbered cycle then it greatly reduces the chance of synchronizing with a predator.
- defen 17y agoI was living in Princeton when these little bastards made their appearance in 2004. Just one bug can produce an impressively loud sound - so you can imagine what millions sound like. And there's nothing like walking to work through heaps of bug carcasses.
- jrockway 17y agoYeah, I hate experiencing nature for one week every 17 years. We should agent-orange the trees they are feeding on, and stop the cycle forever. Let's also pump a bunch of toxic gas into the atmosphere to block out the sun and stop global warming. What could go wrong!
- rthomas6 17y agoYes, I'm sure that's exactly what he meant. Chill out man. People are allowed to think things are fascinating and kind of annoying at the same time.
- petercooper 17y agoLet's also pump a bunch of toxic gas into the atmosphere to block out the sun and stop global warming. What could go wrong! Oh come on, it's not that bad! You'll be able to enjoy "experiencing nature" for a week when a flood or tornado sweeps through your house. As a nature fan, you'll love it.
- 17y ago
- machrider 17y agoI was half-expecting the prime-number-shitting bear: http://alpha61.com/primenumbershittingbear/ http://alpha61.com/primenumbershittingbear/
- jrockway 17y agoNot what I was expecting. But upon reflection, that page is exactly as advertised.
- btilly 17y agoIt is interesting, but I'm curious how a paper got written on this in 2001 and accepted. It is the same explanation that Stephen J. Gould wrote a popular essay on many years earlier.
- ANH 17y agoThere's nothing like cycling every day through a cloud of cicadas for a couple of weeks, as I did in Virginia in 2004. Not only are they noisy before mating, but they make a very loud thwack when hitting a bicycle helmet.
- Daniel_Newby 17y agoThe prime numbers have nothing to do with predators. Predators require regular feeding from live prey. A prey species that hides for even one year causes significant starvation in predators that could otherwise come to depend on it. This effect is maximized after only a handful of years of hiding. No lizard or bird could survive on stored fat for more than one or two years. The prime numbers come from competition between strains of cicadas. First consider that genetic timers are not perfect: most cicadas may emerge after N years, but a fraction will emerge in N-1, N+1, or even farther years due to randomness in genetics and the environment. By blind chance, occasionally an early group will become plentiful, causing a predator population boom that smashes the population of the "correct" year. It's like a badly-made gear that occasionally jumps one tooth forward. Second consider what such jumping does to strains that are not relatively prime, such as 6 and 12 year cicadas. Eventually the random chance effect will synchronize them so that they emerge in the same year. Because these year skipping cicadas all evolved from the same parent species, they will be closely related. This creates a cross-mating problem if they emerge at the same time, causing matings to either produce no offspring, or to produce hybrids that are synchronized with neither period. There may also be problems with excess damage to the host plants. Therefore evolution favors strains that synchronize as infrequently as possible. That means prime numbers. IIRC a few years back some scientists created a simulation with plausible numbers for fertility and hybrids, and the result was spontaneous emergence of the prime number periods for the observed strains of cicadas. Edited for clarity.
- Mz 17y agoAnd this is comment number 17! (It would be funny if the discussion stopped here. :-D)