3 ms·
Deletionism is a sad, bizarre chapter in human history whose last pages are even now being written. But what can we radical inclusionists do in the meantime?
by gojomo 17y ago
Deletionism is a sad, bizarre chapter in human history whose last pages are even now being written.
But what can we radical inclusionists do in the meantime?
The articles that do survive deletionism are useful, and important. Wikipedia remains a cultural treasure. So, the proper response to deletionism is not to boycott or withdraw from Wikipedia, but offer qualified support of the common base, all the while preparing for the eventual, inevitable, glorious inclusionist fork.
More of my reasoning here: http://memesteading.com/2010/03/15/dialectical-inclusionism/ http://memesteading.com/2010/03/15/dialectical-inclusionism/
- orblivion 17y agoThis fork could be, articles as they appear it Wikipedia, plus other articles that weren't accepted. However, what about deletionists affecting the edits of existing articles? Swiping Wikipedia's history, and keeping your articles in line with that would be a serious pain.
- dantheman 17y agoWikipedia could easily set a flag that says how core the article is and then users could select the level of inclusion or notoriety they want to see. It'd also be awesome if on every page they included some sort of visualization of editing activity & population of editors and the amount of viewers who have looked at the article in relation to the edits. This way a user can get a feeling of how many eyeballs have been on the page.
- orblivion 17y agoThis should supposedly be active by now: http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2009/08/wikitrust/ http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2009/08/wikitrust/ from a quick look I can't figure out how to turn it on.
- gojomo 17y agoTrying to run a site that's exactly Wikipedia/MediaWiki, but inclusive, could be hard -- given the preexistence of Wikipedia, and the difficulties of attracting a critical mass to an almost-the-same project. Such a simple fork might be stuck as a sickly sibling for a long time. Instead, I believe the inclusionist alternative will have to change some of the core dynamics of Wikipedia -- solving some of the tensions that have motivated deletionism in other ways, while creating out a distinct competitive identity. I have some ideas, which I'll be writing more about soon. But a major theme is: there's plenty of room at the bottom.
- prodigal_erik 17y agoHow far does radical inclusionism go? I mean, you don't want to see every document on the web migrated to wikipedia, do you? What belongs there?
- gojomo 17y agoTo a large extent Wikipedia serves as reference/summarization -- lossy 'compression' of a sort -- for source materials. So my tentative standard would be: is a significantly shorter version of the source material still true and useful? If so, it's legitimate for inclusion in my hypothetical everything-is-on-topic Wikipedia offshoot. (Compare this idea to the theory behind the 'Hutter Prize' -- http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hutter_Prize http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hutter_Prize -- that advances in compressing Wikipedia imply progress in artificial intelligence.) You even potentially want many articles per topic, based on the reader's patience (or initial level of competence). The 1-sentence version for the casual reader in a hurry. The 1-minute version. The 10-minutes version. The 1-hour version for a keenly-interested researcher who already knows adjacent topics well. (If these already exist elsewhere, include them by reference, but build out the open encyclopedia with them as needed to fill gaps in the coverage or quality of other sources.)