7 ms·
I2P: Invisible Internet Protocol
- 616c 10y agoI have always found it more interesting than Tor. After learning some Java, I read through the code, even compiled seminole Monotone DVCS(ironically difficult, because of the recently mentioned legacy version of the Botan C++ crypto library), but it is all a little beyond me. Perhaps one of the coolest projects I'd seen in a while was Nightweb, a I2P-layered distributed social network, written in Clojure, flashing all the hipster programming bling as it be. https://github.com/oakes/Nightweb https://github.com/oakes/Nightweb I have always wondered if it gets the same level of scrutiny or interest from researchers or nation states, as it was largely self-contained and not meant to onion route to public Internet like Tor (judging from my reading of the design). Please, HNers, school me and impress me with your I2P trivia and knowledge.
- kseistrup 10y agoNightweb is discontinued ⌘ https://sekao.net/nightweb/blog/discontinued.html https://sekao.net/nightweb/blog/discontinued.html
- 616c 10y agoYeah, was sad to read Reddit when it happened.
- cloudjacker 10y agoI2P interest and development has grown with the direct monetization path of more anonymous cryptocurrencies that have attempted to partner with I2P over the years, such as Monero There have been other cryptocurrencies that had the ethos of being anonymous, such as "anoncoin" but functioned exactly like bitcoin and never was able to develop their obfuscation layer It is all still in its infancy
- 616c 10y agoHas it? I had not heard of Monero. You got stuff I can read? I am curious about the I2P culture, if you are in the know.
- cloudjacker 10y agoNone of the cryptocurrency communities have successfully integrated with I2P. The primary goal being to include a native I2P routing client within all of the respective cryptocurrency's daemon's and client software. (Most cryptocurrencies broadcast a lot of information about you to the nodes, and when you really dive into it, the result is a little unsettling. In this regard it is kind of like bittorrent where other peers in the network can see information about you.) As far as formal partnerships go, Anoncoin was the closest, where they got some public mention from the I2P stewards, and had icons on the I2P dashboard when you logged into that darknet. Anoncoin's steward disappeared with an unsuccessful zerocoin implementation and exit scam. This was 2014. Monero is an opaque blockchain that has worked out of the box as a private cryptocurrency since early 2014. My cryptocurrency market capitalization, it has remained around #10 for two years. It is one of the more actively developed cryptocurrencies, and I2P integration is still on their roadmap. There's nothing else to really say about I2P. There hasn't been much public research into how it works or vulnerabilities, as with the TOR network. I understand it works quite a bit differently, and what I do know is appealing. But it is currently "meh". Some sites that are super annoying to TOR users, work extremely well under I2P and don't detect that you are not a clearnet user.
- 616c 10y agoI had the same reaction, but largely because I2P is under the radar; Tor gets a lot more attention, in both the good ways and bad.
- plasticmachine 10y agoMonero has got an I2P router in C++ as one of their projects: https://github.com/monero-project/kovri https://github.com/monero-project/kovri If you want some general information on Monero then this is a good talk on Bitcoin privacy and on what Monero is and does: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVlQE-ObEXk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YVlQE-ObEXk
- petra 10y ago>> I have always wondered if it gets the same level of scrutiny or interest from researchers or nation states My guess is the I2P gets more scrutiny from the US government, because it's much harder to break versus TOR(for which there we're always probably some attacks). It might even be that TOR is a government response for the demand for anonymizing networks - funded specifically in order for the anonymity community to do something else than I2P and anonymous remailers, and seems that the community mostly went with it.
- 616c 10y ago>> My guess is the I2P gets more scrutiny from the US government, because it's much harder to break versus TOR How so? Is this what is alluded to by "onion vs garlic" routing design? http://resources.infosecinstitute.com/anonymizing-networks-tor-vs-i2p/ http://resources.infosecinstitute.com/anonymizing-networks-t... (I can't get the I2P explanation/comparison on their official site right now; not sure it's me or them, haha.) Again, I read a while back. I am pleased to know it is more secure. Personally, I liked they had easily accessible Android builds directly from them at the time. But the Tor devs do so much good development, tech writing on the blog, and research publication it is hard to love or hate either group as they save the Internet from itself.
- pwg 10y ago>> My guess is the I2P gets more scrutiny from the US government, because it's much harder to break versus TOR > How so? Is this what is alluded to by "onion vs garlic" routing design? For one, it is a closed overlay network. There are no "exit nodes" (well, not unless someone explicitly setup a proxy to provide "exit" functionality). So everything that happens anywhere within I2P remains inside I2P. So any attacks on TOR that require control of one or more exit nodes in the TOR network to function will not directly function against I2P (no exit nodes). Now, that has no bearing upon whether there are other, different, exploits in I2P that would break its hidden aspects, but you can at least know you are immune when using I2P to any TOR exploit that requires exit nodes.
- 10y ago
- syngrog66 10y ago> Please, HNers, school me and impress me with your I2P trivia and knowledge. even if you didn't ask this, this is what many HN users would feel they read. Be prepared for a flood of replies telling you precisely how you are not quite perfectly right, or, are blatantly wrong and moronic, because they themselves are perfect and all-knowing, and you yourself must be lacking in the department of subtlely and nuance. ;-)
- seibelj 10y agoI read through some of the high level docs, but can someone simply explain how a user discovers other nodes in the network? I started reading the netDB docs [0] but it was pretty dense. [0] https://geti2p.net/en/docs/how/network-database https://geti2p.net/en/docs/how/network-database
- TaroAnami 10y agoI entered here for the same question. I offer one million internet points to whoever answers this. Thank you!
- thatcat 10y agoFrom the Bootstrapping section of the link you provided.. >volunteers publish their netDb directories (or a subset) on the regular (non-i2p) network, and the URLs of these directories are hardcoded in I2P. When the router starts up for the first time, it automatically fetches from one of these URLs, selected at random.
- seibelj 10y agoOK, so you put your IP address into several centralized DB's on the regular internet, then when I2P starts it randomly fetches from one of those repositories.
- thatcat 10y agoYea, tor basically does the same thing.
- Natanael_L 10y agoThe only not totally implausible alternative is broadcasting addresses over amateur radio
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- PieterH 10y agoIt would be really cool to have an I2P transport in ZeroMQ, and could be quite simple as I2P's messaging maps directly to the datagram model ZeroMQ uses. Or vice-versa.
- plasticmachine 10y agoSurely this is better suited to ZMTP than 0MQ?
- robert_foss 10y agoI2P developer here, feel free to ask me any questions.
- atemerev 10y agoWho is zzz? :)
- robert_foss 10y agozzz is our BDFL. If you really would like to know, come meet the I2P folks at 33C3 or potentially HOPE if you live in NA. CCC is better since I2P typically has a table there.
- daxorid 10y agoWill you be around for bsides lv or defcon?
- robert_foss 10y agoNo, not this year. Some I2P folk might be, but we as a project won't attend.
- hkparker 10y agoThanks for contributing to I2P! Do you have any thoughts on HORNET? Could I2P benefit from a more stateless routing mechanism as opposed to tunnels in the far future? Are any of the devs going to defcon this year? I tried to get a small meetup going last year in the privacy village but no turnout, would love to make something official. I'm working on Go implementation here: https://github.com/hkparker/go-i2p https://github.com/hkparker/go-i2p. Haven't made to irc2p to introduce myself yet but I will. Are there any devs who might be interested in contributing? Privacy of developers seems a priority. Without any detail of course, can you comment on how necessary this has been. Is it irresponsible of me to work on an implementation in the clear?
- 10y ago
- hkparker 10y agoGood to see I2P get some attention here. For those who don't know about I2P: * Anonymity network similar to TOR in some ways, but rather than focusing on getting someone out to the internet anonymously, I2P is a low-latency mix network with no out proxies. See: https://ritter.vg/blog-mix_and_onion_networks.html https://ritter.vg/blog-mix_and_onion_networks.html * Virtually every I2P router relays traffic, unlike TOR the network is very "flat". Directory servers are replaced with a DHT called the netDB. Recently I've been working on a Go implementation of the I2P router: https://github.com/hkparker/go-i2p https://github.com/hkparker/go-i2p. It isn't on the network yet, would be really interested in working with anyone who wants to contribute.
- daxorid 10y agoTo clarify, since modernity has stripped us of patience: "low latency" here means on the order of 1500ms, not tens of ms, as most people expect. As opposed to tens of seconds or minutes in mix message protocols.
- zzzcpan 10y agoAre there JVM-less I2P implementations?
- hkparker 10y agoC++, stable on the network: https://github.com/PurpleI2P/i2pd https://github.com/PurpleI2P/i2pd C++, active development: https://github.com/monero-project/kovri https://github.com/monero-project/kovri Go, pretty new (my project!): https://github.com/hkparker/go-i2p https://github.com/hkparker/go-i2p
- 1ris 10y agoI ran a i2p router for year, mostly because I didn't mind. This is a kind of a hen-egg-problem, I guess. There is not any content in i2p I'm aware off besides a torrent site. And I probably don't want to know what the content is I'm not aware of. While I think this is in theory much cooler than tor, it's a way less practical, i guess.
- p4bl0 10y agoMay I interest you in a copy of my webpage (which is not a torrent site) at http://p4bl0.i2p/ http://p4bl0.i2p/ ;-p.
- anonbanker 10y agomany i2p sites stick with the b32 name, for added security through obscurity. Anecdotally, I've seen a lot of document management and ERP servers running on I2P. Bandwidth is decent, and you can't beat the security.
- p4bl0 10y agoMaybe the title should be fixed (s/Protocol/Project/)?
- Zhycrin 10y agoTor vs I2P? Oh boy, all we need is a cnet battle...
- robert_foss 10y agoI2P vs Tor is common topic, but the reality is that the projects are quite different while aiming to serve many of the same goals. I2P is decentralized and Tor offers exit nodes for example. But both projects serve to maintain the option of free speech on the internet, no matter how digitally repressive the country you happen to live in might be (US/China/Iran/Syria).
- asab 10y agoComparison to Tor: https://geti2p.net/en/comparison/tor https://geti2p.net/en/comparison/tor
- wangtang69 10y agoKovri is more secure than i2pd. Don't trust i2pd.