5 ms·
Maybe the other employee had a health issue that prevented them from wearing dress shoes, and management didn't want to share that private information? It defi
by StavrosK 10y ago
Maybe the other employee had a health issue that prevented them from wearing dress shoes, and management didn't want to share that private information?
It definitely sounds like management would prefer to force the lone employee to follow dress code than to allow everyone else to break it.
- masklinn 10y ago> Maybe the other employee had a health issue They did, they had lost a leg, which the interns didn't know beforehand. > management didn't want to share that private information? Except they shared that information… after firing all the interns: > We were told to hand in our ID badges and to gather our things and leave the property ASAP. […] just before the meeting ended, one of the managers told us that the worker who was allowed to disobey the dress code was a former soldier who lost her leg and was therefore given permission to wear whatever kind of shoes she could walk in.
- StavrosK 10y agoAh, right, I didn't read this article (I read the one that was on the front page again earlier today). I think the interns were excessive in making a petition just for changing the dress code, because that can be interpreted as a hostile move, and the company was excessive in firing them, because that's tyrannical and destroys morale. Pretty much everyone involved here was being a dick.
- dogma1138 10y agoHow's the company was excessive? this is the only thing you can do really in this case. She talked to her manager and was stricken down, then she decided to make a petition in order to bully her bosses? She knew exactly what she was doing "oh I don't have much experience in the work force" ehm yeah I'm pretty sure everyone has at least limited understanding of how management works - it's not a democracy, you don't get want you want and you especially don't get it by forcing the hands of your employers. So no not everyone involved here was a dick, there was a brat on one side that decided to effectively unionize the internets over shoes and a company that would not be able to function if a petition means that employees not to mention interns get whatever they want. Day 1 - petition for shoes. Day 3 - petition for bagels. Day 7 - ????
- StavrosK 10y agoBecause it's not reasonable for a company to fire people who unionize. They could have just said "again, no, you have to follow the dress code".
- dogma1138 10y agoThis isn't a union this is a petition, a company works because there is a chain of command this is why being fired for insubordination is a thing. You can't cave to pointless demands of interns especially after you already said no to them, you don't need to give them a justification when your boss says no arguing continuing on arguing with them is usually pointless unless the circumstances changed. Passing around a petition to force the hands of your managers would never lead to good results, this isn't about employee rights this isn't about unions this is about young people acting up because likely no one to that point ever said no to them because they were too afraid. I've seen what happens in schools lately at least in higher education where teachers seem to be afraid of their students rather than the other way around, I somehow feel lucky that I was at the borders of this generation before things went out of head and I remember when being rude to a teach or disruptive in class meant a call to my parents and a whole lot of trouble to me. We somehow went from standing up when the teacher enters the classroom and showing respect to showing the middle finger and getting angry parents defending their kids because they are special. We went from higher education being a place of critical thought where people were challenged with multiple views and paradigms to a place of safe spaces where students can rally because a teacher hurts their feeling when they talk about touchy subjects. It seems that over a few decades we went from a society that aimed for the stars and challenged everything to an infantile group that things that cuddling each other is the most important thing in life because everyone is special in their own way. And I'm really happy that these for lack of a better word "kids" learned this the hard way and early enough that they might still snap out of it, no one owes you anything not even an explanation, life isn't a democracy at best it's a meritocracy you are valued based on what your actively bring to the table not merely because you exist.
- cam_l 10y agoSeems to me you two are arguing (as so many seem to on HN) at cross purposes. One is saying "this is the way the world works", the other is saying "this is the way the world should work". You can acknowledge one, and strive for the other, at the same time. But then amusingly, your plaintive comment on "how things are" quickly turns into an impassioned rant about "how things should be" - which funnily enough is just how things used to be. Maybe you learnt the rules, you did the hard yards, you are just starting to get ahead, and now these upstarts are trying to change the rules. Your whole argument turns on respecting the power structures of the status quo. It seems so horribly entitled to suggest that because the current power structure of organisations support dictator style management, that one cannot try to find ways to undermine that power structure. Organising, complaining, publicly naming and shaming, are just some of the levers to pull to try to readjust the current power structures in your favour.. and why wouldn't you? What manager respects and rewards quiet acquiescence?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- travmatt 10y agoThe article mentions the other employee is a military veteran and amputee who is more comfortable outside the strict dress code. An intern decided they were going to try and force a companies hand and was fired. Not much to see here.