3 ms·
But if Yelp differentially applies policies to nudge a business down to 3 stars -- then what? Anecdotal evidence continues to emerge that Yelp's black-box filt
by gojomo 17y ago
But if Yelp differentially applies policies to nudge a business down to 3 stars -- then what?
Anecdotal evidence continues to emerge that Yelp's black-box filters against 'suspicious' reviews have a strictness dial controlled by ad payments.
- jrockway 17y agoIs there a law that says that you have to follow policies if you are a user-driven site that asks for advertising money? Not that I know of. I used to delete comments from my blog all the time, and now I don't allow them at all. If I had advertising, would I be violating some rule? Then how is Yelp any different, except that people blindly trust it?
- gojomo 17y agoI'd agree Yelp has no obligation to carry any particular review, and good reasons to keep their algorithms and policies somewhat obscured. But traditional journalism and review outlets keep a clear separation between advertising and editorial decisions. Similarly, in finance, a 'Chinese wall' prevents information and revenue from some clients from influencing investment recommendations. And on the internet, Google got more respect than Go/Overture and other competitors by clearly marking advertising, and committing in no uncertain terms to the principle that 'organic' results were uninfluenced by ad-spending. If Yelp wants to blaze a new trail, where review placements and ratings are for sale, I'm sure they can legally do so -- but then Yelp needs to make the proper disclosures, and take the reputational hit that entails. Otherwise they're deceiving people -- which invites lawsuits for unfair trade practices and the attention of regulatory agencies like the FTC. (Facebook is likely to face the same disclosure issues if they ever let companies pay to highlight or bury comments on 'Fan' pages.)