3 ms·
Of note, from the amazon review: "But before we get to that: I received this product at a discount in return for writing an honest review of it. Onwards!" Coul
by r00fus 10y ago
Of note, from the amazon review: "But before we get to that: I received this product at a discount in return for writing an honest review of it. Onwards!"
Could that have anything to do with the manufacturer's attitude?
- maxerickson 10y agoI sort of wonder if Amazon is the entity providing the discount. (I spent a minute trying to figure it out and didn't find anything)
- thesimon 10y agoNo, because these seem to be clearly marked with a Amazon Vine logo and disclaimer.
- ukyrgf 10y agoUp until just now I assumed Amazon Vine had something to do with Vine.co. I didn't realize Vines were only 8 seconds which would be an impractical format for reviews...
- mmanfrin 10y agoNope, there's a cottage industry of review-for-discount sites that give people discounts/free items in exchange for reviews, but wink wink don't feel obligated to give it 5 stars.
- joepvd 10y agoWould the rep who claims to be in fear of losing her/his job be employed from that cottage industry? That would make the claim sound a bit more plausible, assuming, of course malice in the review-for-discount corps.
- daveloyall 10y agoI bet you are on to something. But I have never heard of this review-for-discount concept. I have heard of organizations like this: http://revleap.me/ http://revleap.me/ (I'm sure these guys are completely innocent, they just happened to come up in a DDG search for "get positive amazon reviews".) If you search for "work from home" you will find lots of shady organizations paying people (pennies) to post reviews, for example on Google Maps. It's not a huge leap to imagine a service which pays random online workers to contact negative reviewers with sob stories begging for the review to be removed. And it's not hard to imagine that a disposable worker such as that would indeed be fired (simply not offered additional work) if s/he fails to get a review removed. The organization I linked too shows a picture of what appears to be some kind of negative review alert delivered to a smart phone.
- ohjeez 10y agoNo winking is necessary. Back when I was among the Top Amazon Reviewers, I'd regularly be asked to review products and (especially) books (primarily those that were self published). I rarely said yes, but when I did I treated them exactly the same as I would for a product I'd bought myself. That included 1- and 2-star reviews... though usually I tried to weed out the crap before saying Yes to such an offer. The cost really never influenced me. I can afford a $10 novel that I'm interested in. So if you give me that book for free, it's no big deal. In point of fact I learned to say No to most such offers. Usually novels are self-published only when the author cannot find a traditional publisher. And the traditional publishers usually refuse the book for a good reason. I don't want to waste my time reading crap.... not when there are so many good books to read instead. Also, the self-published authors really didn't like it when I gave their books less than 5 stars, and magically the review would be downvoted -- as well as the last three unrelated items I'd reviewed. Presumably those neginators were from the author's friends and family. So I just said No, and moved on to books from authors I was sure I'd like.
- Peretus 10y agoI can second this. I design, import, and sell products on Amazon, and when launching a new product I offer them for free or at a deeply discounted price to people who agree to provide an honest review. From my experience, across hundreds of transactions, I can say that reviews that are solicited with free or discounted products are much tougher than those received organically. Most people participating in these review groups are so concerned about being viewed as biased that they move far, far in the other direction. If your product can earn decent ratings with incentivized reviews, you'll do very well with organic reviews.
- lawnchair_larry 10y agoThis is deceptive and you should stop doing it.
- Peretus 10y agoWould you mind describing what part of this is deceptive? Amazon offers its own product-to-review system called Vine that is invite-only. Not all sellers can participate in the Vine program as it's available to Vendor Central sellers, meaning that Amazon purchases the products directly and lists them as 'ships from and sold by Amazon'. https://www.amazon.com/gp/vine/help https://www.amazon.com/gp/vine/help Additionally, on each review, the reviewer is required to explain that they received the product in exchange for a review. How would you recommend getting reviews for a product, apart from offering them at a discount? Edit: Added link to Vine FAQ
- StavrosK 10y agoI don't doubt you, but not everything is like this. Newark sent me a few free items (a BeagleBone and a CodeBug) a few months ago, so that I would review them, but on my condition that the review be honest. I ended up publishing a glowing review of the CodeBug anyway (https://www.stavros.io/posts/codebug-review/ https://www.stavros.io/posts/codebug-review/), but that's because I sincerely enjoyed it. I didn't get around to doing anything with the BeagleBone, sadly. Maybe that's why they didn't send me anything else, though :P