3 ms·
I quit after the abstract. No one ever said something was quantum because the number 2 * sqrt(2) appeared, kind of like no one really thinks that something is
by amluto 10y ago
I quit after the abstract. No one ever said something was quantum because the number 2 * sqrt(2) appeared, kind of like no one really thinks that something is a circle just because you can coax pi out of it.
Now, if they actually violated Bell's inequality in a non-quantum experiment in which Bell's inequality were actually applicable, that would be huge news (and grounds to try to confirm the results). But finding a number that violates it out of context isn't news at all.
tl:dr 2.78 3.14. Hence this post is quantum and circular.
- sp332 10y agoI take your point about this paper, but if pi shows up, I would absolutely suspect a circle to be involved.
- Aelinsaar 10y ago>if pi shows up, I would absolutely suspect a circle to be involved Now that is a T-Shirt.
- srtjstjsj 10y agoWhere there's smoke, there's a pyre, too. Where there's circle, there's a pi r two
- drdeca 10y agoApparently for a 2d convex hull, the perimeter of it is pi times the mead width of it. Does that count as a circle being involved? I guess if you showed that the perimeter was proportional to the mean width, then circles would prove that the constant of proportion would be pi, because pi is (often? by definition) the perimeter of the circle divided by the (constant) width. I don't know if you count that as a circle being involved.
- seandougall 10y agoI would. Pi is (indeed always) the circumference of a circle divided by its diameter. To calculate the perimeter of a 2d convex hull, my impulse would be to model the shape in polar coordinates and integrate over theta. The fact that this calculation relies on polar coordinates strongly implies a relationship to circles -- specifically, L = 2 * pi * r_mean turns out to be unsurprising, since you're basically treating each slice of the hull as a slice of a circle, and calculation based on that circle's radius.
- drdeca 10y agoby usually I meant that is usually how it is defined. Of course it is always true that it is that value, I just meant, like, what description of the value is used to define what value we mean. I was unclear on that part. I meant that I think that in most cases, pi = circumference / diameter is the definition of pi, rather than pi being defined in some other way, and it being proven as a theorem that pi = circumference / diameter. Like, suppose I defined pi as sqrt(6*Zeta(2)) , this would still be the same value, so it would work as a definition of pi, but I don't think it is often defined in a way like this. I think I mostly wrote ^ because I felt like the way I worded my previous comment could be misinterpreted in a way that I feel would make me look dumb, so I wanted to clarify what I actually meant. Your point about considering it in polar coordinates seems like a good explanation. I hadn't thought of that, I like it, thank you for that. I don't yet see how to make that rigorous, but it sounds like it makes sense in a nice way. Thank you.
- ccvannorman 10y agoThere are many ways to arrive at Pi which themselves are quite divorced from "a circle", since you could arrive at the conclusion in a one dimensional Universe. It's true that if you were to graph these equations you would see circles, but that is besides the point - a one dimensional being wouldn't be able to understand your graph, but could still read you the digits of pi. http://www.geom.uiuc.edu/~huberty/math5337/groupe/expresspi.html http://www.geom.uiuc.edu/~huberty/math5337/groupe/expresspi....
- sp332 10y agoThe first one there is derived from a definition of a circle: x^2 + y^2 = c. Most of the rest use an arctangent. Only the last one is not obviously related to a circle. We are in 3 dimensions but we use higher dimensional math all the time, so I don't know why a 1D creature would be so constrained.