4 ms·
> After skimming the document for 15 minutes, I didn't find a single thing that would be insightful to experienced software developers or their managers That's
by lisper 10y ago
> After skimming the document for 15 minutes, I didn't find a single thing that would be insightful to experienced software developers or their managers
That's because the purpose of this document is not to advance the process of producing safe software, it is to facilitate the process of assigning blame when something goes wrong, and in particular to help deflect blame from upper management and onto a scapegoat lower down on the food chain. This document is not operative in the forward direction, i.e. it is not the case that people read it and acquire knowledge which they then use to write better software. It is operative in the reverse direction, i.e. when something goes wrong, upper management scours the document to find a place where whatever went wrong deviated from the rules. They then say, "Look, it's not out fault, we had the right rules in place. It is the fault of whoever deviated from the rules."
This is not a phenomenon unique to NASA, BTW. Most large bureaucratic organizations eventually develop this dynamic.
- cpeterso 10y agoI read a somewhat tongue-in-cheek blog post about "blame-oriented software design". I can't find it now, but it had actually useful advice on design techniques like logging and API precondition checks to avoid blame for other people's bugs. :)