2 ms·
This article nearly pegs my bogometer. It reads more like numerology than science. Yes, it is true that quantum bounds "arise naturally" from quantum theory,
by lisper 10y ago
This article nearly pegs my bogometer. It reads more like numerology than science. Yes, it is true that quantum bounds "arise naturally" from quantum theory, but what matters is not that they arise but how they arise, and on this the article is completely mute. The mere fact that you can coax the same numbers out of a classical experiment is completely meaningless. What matters is how you coax those numbers out, and in particular, whether the manner in which you coaxed those numbers out involved a quantum effect or simply manipulating unconstrained degrees of freedom to get the result you want. There may be something interesting going on here, but there is no way to tell from reading this article. If you really could get a quantum bound out of a classical system in a non-bogus way, that would be big news, the biggest breakthrough in physics in decades. I'll give you long odds against.
- gone35 10y agoIndeed. From the discussion section of their paper: "This shows that quantum correlations can be universally recreated with classical systems at the expense of some extra resources" (Emphasis added) I might be wrong, but judging from Fig. 1 in the paper, it seems these "extra resources" involved are exponential, which is exactly what we would expect since we already know arbitrary quantum circuits can be simulated classically with exponential slowdown! But I guess the setup is interesting in of itself --from an experimentalist point of view at least.
- lisper 10y agoThat is exactly the sentence that I was about to point out!