4 ms·
Curious whether this precedent could be used to argue that Snowden acted legally. After all, leaks happen routinely, and the technical difficulty of copying do
by nostrademons 10y ago
Curious whether this precedent could be used to argue that Snowden acted legally. After all, leaks happen routinely, and the technical difficulty of copying documents onto a thumb drive is minimal. Clearly, then, the NSA has no reasonable expectation of privacy for any document that it keeps in electronic form.
- apendleton 10y agoDoubtful. Expectations of privacy and their bearings on 4th amendment search reasonableness don't have much to do with Snowden's case. The NSA isn't arguing that a government search was unreasonable, nor are their expectations germane; what Snowden took wasn't "private" in a 4th amendment sense, it was classified, and he'd be prosecuted under the Espionage Act.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- jliptzin 10y agoYou could argue that, but you wouldn't win, despite that being a logical next step to this ruling. Judges and legislators today seem to arrive at their preferred judgment first, then work backwards to see what kinds of precedents or reasoning they could massage to justify their rulings. If you're looking for consistency and logic in the US justice system you're going to be disappointed.
- wry_discontent 10y agoTo completely fair, that's how most regular people make decisions too.
- Grishnakh 10y agoMost regular people are idiots and have little grasp of formal logic. Judges are supposed to be experts at the law and better at this stuff than "regular normal people". That's why they spend years in law school, and why judges aren't just randomly selected from the general population.
- zanny 10y agoConsidering that in many places judges are elected, I'd consider that fairly close to randomly selected. Nobody is being particularly ardent in their vote for judges, and as a result basically anyone who runs for the position with the largest advertising budget can win.
- Grishnakh 10y agoElected judges made sense back in the frontier days, just like elected county clerks. These days, they simply don't. They need to eliminate that entirely. These positions should be appointed by elected state legislatures or elected county governance boards (actually, the clerk position should simply be a salaried employee position).
- conceit 10y agoPeople have an OK grasp of formal logic, that is the formalism. It's learned at an early age, it's prerequisite for deductive (or inductive?) learning actually. Most might lack the cognitive ability to exercise those formalism in an abstract synthesis into long formulas.
- woodman 10y agoNo, people suck at it - just look at your first sentence. There are a lot of likely reasons, my favorite being evolutionary pressure: 10,000 years ago two men see the tall grass twitch, while one scrambles up a nearby tree the other considers the cost in energy expenditure to flee vs the likelihood of a tiger attAAARGH. We can't trust brains to the point where we have to invent highly structured methods: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analysis_of_competing_hypotheses https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Analysis_of_competing_hypothes...
- conceit 10y agoWhat's got energy expenditure to do with logic? Isn't what you talk about Bayesian Inference? > while one scrambles up a nearby tree I'm not sure that is just a nervous reflex or the result of the logic implication "If that's a Tiger and I stay then I will die". Even if the thought becomes hardwired, it would have to have been logically evaluated before it became subconscious. To react and be afraid, the danger must be recognized and categorized, "If the grass twitches then something moved it", etc. etc. Going down that argument, small life forms would be able of some small amount of logic reasoning, too. As long as those grow bulks of neurons, I don't see why that should be wrong. > just look at your first sentence What are you trying to say?
- ikeboy 10y ago>despite that being a logical next step to this ruling No. No it isn't. This ruling does not state that hacking is legal, it says that it isn't a 4th Amendment violation. As I said in https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12016508 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12016508 >Someone not having a reasonable expectation of privacy in a thing does not mean it is legal to hack their computer. And there's an explicit legal exemption of hacking for law enforcement in the CFAA.
- conceit 10y ago> to arrive at their preferred judgment first > then ... to justify their rulings Well, unless justification and judgment aren't pretty much synonym, that's a contradiction? The subconscious decision met by such a judge should be guided by an organic sound understanding of justice. The verbalization of this kind of emotion should only bring up the true reasons of thought, maybe polished and cut short. At least, that would be my lame excuse.
- WhoBeI 10y agoNo, it can't. He signed a bunch of documents where he promised to not disclose anything. He was perfectly aware that he was violating those agreements as well as probably both civil and military law. Regardless of how important an impact the release had he's still a traitor to the US. No number of "privacy is an illusion" rulings will change that. I presume that capital punishment is an option for traitors which makes getting of the hacking charge a minor thing anyways.
- nxzero 10y agoNo law legally is able to force anyone to not disclose illegal acts. In the case of Snowden, question is if the acts disclosed were illegal.
- ikeboy 10y agoIt's clear that not everything disclosed was illegal under US law, there's no real case to be made that it was.
- monocasa 10y agoNot everything disclosed in the Pentagon Papers was illegal either. If the requirement is that everything in the disclosure needs to be illegal, then whistleblowing is de facto illegal.
- ikeboy 10y agoReleasing the Pentagon papers was illegal, but Ellsberg's prosecutors messed up, violated the law in a number of ways themselves, so he got off. The way to whistleblow legally is either to carefully go over the material and only release parts that are illegal, or report it to the higher authorities instead of the public.
- dredmorbius 10y agoThe TFA case concerns 4th amendment rights against self-incrimination. Snowden's case isn't a 4th amendment case. Therefor, precedent, if any (and Reilly seems to specifically trump the judge's decision) wouldn't apply. Snowden's various NSA oaths are supersceded by his oath to uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States. Which he did.
- dredmorbius 10y agoInteresting suggestion, but no. Snowden wasn't acting as a law enforcement officer performing a search of personal information subject to the 4th Amendement, but as a citizen and US Government employee or contractor, having sworn an oath to defend and protect the Constitution, to do so through exercise of his own 1st Amendment free speech rights. And should be lawful under those grounds.