4 ms·
It is a challenging definition, but I would argue that it is not. Because while the core OS is open, you are not effectively able to fork it. Google's developer
by ocdtrekkie 10y ago
It is a challenging definition, but I would argue that it is not. Because while the core OS is open, you are not effectively able to fork it. Google's developer advocates heavily encourages the use of proprietary Google APIs in app development, which binds those apps to Google's proprietary packages.
I guess the question is how you define a platform or an operating system, but I think that the platform apps on it run off of is a major part of it. And the difference in what will run on AOSP and what will run on Google Play flavored Android is staggering.
- cm3 10y agoIs there a page to check what popular app does not work on F-Droid or Cyanogen? Say something like Nokia's mapping app.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI don't know, but please tell me if you find one. I have F-Droid and Play on my phone, and disabled Google Play Services to see how many of the apps I have installed and use continued to work. Many gave me "must update Play Services" dialogs, some just crashed outright. I've been trying to transition to open apps or apps available outside the Play Store, but unfortunately, Skype is one need I can't work around right now.
- cm3 10y agoI suppose Skype might work in a mobile browser via WebRTC, but from what I gather it's not there yet.
- dublinben 10y agoYou can be pretty certain that any free software apps found in F-Droid will not require proprietary Google APIs. Every other app in the Play Store can be assumed to require them.