3 ms·
But does an offence of J walking for someone on probation breach that probation? Genuine question as I don't know. But essentially laws like that become tools
by ehnto 10y ago
But does an offence of J walking for someone on probation breach that probation?
Genuine question as I don't know. But essentially laws like that become tools with which law enforcement can excercise malice toward individuals if they please.
I am reminded of a story of a man out on probation, who used a knife for his work. He had been out for a while, normally the knife was concealed as it's required to be. But it was visible when he was stopped on his way home from work. The state of New York has pretty strict laws at their disposal, and they chose to use them in this case, and the man who had been getting his life back together was thrown back in jail over what is essentially a technicality.
Laws that seem harmless and unenforced should be removed, less they be abused. Just like it is best to remove a deprecated function when it's no longer in use, lest it become a risk.
- Bromskloss 10y agoWhy is the knife supposed to be concealed? What difference does that make?
- csixty4 10y agoIf it's the story I'm thinking of, GP has the details a little mixed up. But it's been a few years since the story broke so that's understandable. The issue was the knife itself being illegal in New York -- a knife that could be bought at almost any hardware or art supply store in the city. Concealed or not, the guy was violating a poorly written law meant to criminalize switchblades in the mid 20th century. But cops had been using it to arrest African American men if they saw the telltale pocket clip while stopping them for something else. They classified this certain kind of utility knife as a "gravity knife", even though it wasn't. The law outlaws knives opened with a flick of the wrist, and it took a cop five tries to flick one open in court once because they aren't designed to be opened that way. But that one time was all it took. To bring this back to the original question: in a just world, an arrest for owning one of these knives -- again, one that you could buy at any hardware store shouldn't violate someone's probation. Neither should jaywalking, something I do countless times a day.
- ehnto 10y agoYou are right, that was the story I was thinking of! Thank you for the correction.
- csixty4 10y agoRichard Neal. His profile in the Village Voice came up in my Twitter feed the other day: http://www.villagevoice.com/news/how-a-50s-era-new-york-knife-law-has-landed-thousands-in-jail-6662589 http://www.villagevoice.com/news/how-a-50s-era-new-york-knif... Its a long read but worth it.
- jghn 10y agoPotentially, but literally no one ever gets yanked for jaywalking. I used to live right down the street from MIT and all sorts of sketchy people stumble their way across streets whenever they feel like it, and that neighborhood has a decent police presence. The original point is still valid, it was just a bad example. No one gets cited for jaywalking here.
- mcguire 10y agoI didn't realize MIT was located in a lower-income, minority neighborhood.
- jghn 10y agoIt's right across the street from one, actually. It also borders Central Square which is home to a lot of derelicts. Things are more gentrified now than they were even 10-15 years ago but the Jaywalking thing has been around for 30ish years.
- runamok 10y agoOne time while walking back from a bar in my mid 20s I ran across a street in front of a police cruiser as the light was yellow and they exerted their power by hassling me and telling my friends to watch out for me. This was Fullerton, CA and I am a short white guy with a shaved head. You may think they were watching out for me but there was significant belligerence. The point is they enforce whatever, whenever. There are far too many laws and they are very unevenly enforced.