3 ms·
I firmly believe that all genetic engineering applications, except for human health-related medical interventions, should be delayed for at least several hundre
by carapace 10y ago
I firmly believe that all genetic engineering applications, except for human health-related medical interventions, should be delayed for at least several hundred years. Research, yes, but applications are out of the question for centuries.
Anything less stringent is open-ended experimentation on the only biosphere in the known Universe. It is hubris of the rankest sort.
Further I believe that this is a scientific view.
We know our ignorance is far too vast.
The only reasons to use GMOs are hubris and greed. That is it.
Either you are a scientific ego-tripper who can't or won't understand that real people have serious reservations about participating in your open-ended genetic experiment, or you just want to make a buck and don't care.
If it could be shown that, for some given application of GE, there is absolutely no other alternative to save lives, then that's something. However, I believe we can feed ourselves without GMOs by means of "applied ecology" ("Permaculture" etc.) so there is no call to use GMOs. These doubtless well-meaning scientists are using the reduction of "Vitamin-A deficiencies causing blindness and death in children in the developing world" to insist on a highly controversial technology. It's kind of just as ugly and self-serving as they paint Greenpeace to be.
The report from the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine is quoted in the article as saying, "such crops are relatively new and that it is premature to make broad generalizations, positive or negative, about their safety."
We know we don't know enough. I don't want to eat your faith.
- sampo 10y ago> I believe that this is a scientific view. > hubris Don't you think there is maybe a little hubris in you thinking you know the scientific view better than 107 Nobel Price winners?
- carapace 10y agoNo. Argument from Authority. There isn't one "the" scientific view. And, in this case, "107 Nobel Price winners" (sic) have said merely, "Greenpeace are superstitious baby-killers." not a scientific repudiation of the points I've raised.
- nitrogen 10y agoScientists' prior experiments with irradiated plants would probably have caused far worse damage by now if GMOs are a significant threat (apart from some hypothetical deliberately malignant possibilities). See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_gardening https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atomic_gardening
- credit_guy 10y agoSeveral hundred years? Research yes, but no applications? Why would anyone put in the effort to do the research, if they know in the best case scenario the applications would come in several hundred years? Now, I understand doubts in our current state of knowledge, and the desire for more knowledge, but consider this: 352 years ago people didn't know about cells, let alone chromosomes, DNA, or the possibility of genetic editing. The concept of GMO probably didn't exist 50 years ago. I don't think any of us has a change to imagine how the world will be in a few hundred years. Did you really mean several hundred years, or several tens of years?
- carapace 10y ago> Why would anyone put in the effort to do the research, if they know in the best case scenario the applications would come in several hundred years? Because they are Scientists. -- Really the point I'm making is that we should be proceeding with GE applications "as an old man crossing a river in Winter" with utmost caution and humility. We should introduce GMOs with the greatest of reluctance, after every other avenue to achieve our goal has been ruled out, not rushing pell-mell like drunken teenagers. I really do mean several centuries. We have only just discovered that the oceans teem with bacteriopages, that biofilms can think, that we have an "organ" called the "microbiome" made up of cells that are genetically not us, that the physical structure of chromosomes influences the decoding of DNA, it goes on and on. New things are discovered daily. I think we should wait until we understand before we manipulate.