33 ms·
The criticism is about the emergent incentives due to the interplay of capitalism and technology. The question is whether the industry can be trusted to self-r
by kristopolous 10y ago
The criticism is about the emergent incentives due to the interplay of capitalism and technology.
The question is whether the industry can be trusted to self-regulate or if there are externalities and endogenous variables which may spur a generalized irresponsible utility.
In the same way that environmentalists criticize coal for its abuses in the context of capital markets, there's a concern that not every for-profit biotech firm will value multi-generational probabilistic long-term effects on an ecosystem as much as the company's business interests.
- twinkletwinkle 10y agoThank you for the cogent framing of the issues. It's so easy to bash GMO skeptics for being "anti science" or stubborn vegan hippies. There are legitimate concerns to discuss.
- tstactplsignore 10y agoSurely this argument can be used to criticize any field, though - "the question is whether the technology industry can be trusted to self-regulate" - "the question is whether the pharmaceutical industry can be trusted to self-regulate"- and so on. If you what you have is a concern about capitalist abuse and are calling for checks on and regulation of corporate power, all the power to you (I strongly support these concerns and calls in all industries). However, to be "anti-GMO" because of what some corporations who make them may do in the future is like being "anti-Internet" or "anti-medicine" for the same reasons.
- kristopolous 10y agoEnvironmentalists are those with concerns about environmental consequences and advocate for scrutiny of things which may lead to them. The organizations chartered with environmental concern decidedly focus on such things. There are certainly people who are anti-internet or anti-medicine, but they are called different things. Additionally there are purely anti-capitalist people. However, one can be pro-capitalist and pro-free market while simultaneously claiming that the tobacco companies violated this trust of the market. People are complex creatures and take on a variety of labels with varying degrees of precision, passion, and commitment.
- panic 10y agoSure, but that doesn't necessarily have to do with GMOs. Say we pass a mandatory GMO labeling law and, in response, Monsanto figures out a way to make pesticide-resistant seeds through normal cross-breeding. Now we're back in the same place we started, except with labels that confuse people into thinking GMOs are bad.
- kristopolous 10y agoSorry but I'm not anti-GMO. I'm for intellectual honesty and believe thoughtful claims should be presented sincerely and carefully as a matter of course whether I support them or not.
- sampo 10y ago> Monsanto figures out a way to make pesticide-resistant seeds through normal cross-breeding. BASF has made, and patented, herbicide resistant wheat, rice, sunflower, lentils, canola and corn. Google 'clearfield production systems'. They are produced by non-GMO technologies.