7 ms·
Devastating Amazon hardware review of a wireless power switch
- jjp 10y agoBe interesting to see whether the reviewer gets any more bargains to review after that?
- oceanswave 10y agoWith a review that thorough, he should get a consultation fee
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agoWeird. I thought the review was myopic.
- jrockway 10y agoYou bring up a very good point. I like reading reviews before I buy things, but with all reviewers basically living off the free stuff they get, I do worry that there is a conflict of interest. I don't imagine they get a lot of email like "you gave our thing a positive review while the rest of the Internet appears to hate it. Your reviews are not very thorough so we're not sending you review units anymore." I bet if you do write a lot of negative reviews, the UPS guy doesn't visit your office as often as the author who writes a lot of positive reviews. Pure speculation of course.
- wuezz 10y ago<3 mjg59
- muratsu 10y agoCan someone explain me "If anybody knows the MAC address of one of your sockets, they can control it from anywhere in the world." part in more detail?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tremon 10y agoin the end the relevant things are just a command and the MAC address of the socket. On the local network this is sent directly to the socket, otherwise it goes via the server in China Anyone can send a command to the server, and the server routes it to your device based on the MAC address in the command.
- BugsBunnySan 10y agoa) the sockets all connect to a central server in China b) the sockets identify themselves to that server with their MAC address (kind of makes sense, it's a readily available, global unique (more or less) identifies) c) if you send a message to a socket (identified by its MAC address) from the app on your phone and your mobile phone can't find it on the local network, the app sends a message to the central server in China, which sends it on to the socket, if that happens to be turned on and is thus connected over the internet to that central server So, it's not that you can suddenly magically access devices by MAC address over the Internet (MAC addresses are still local network only), but since the sockets are all connected to a central server who knows them by their MAC address, that makes it possible to send those messages. This would all not be a problem with good crypto for authentication (and secrecy), but apparently they put pretty much none of that into the product/app. So it should be realtivly easy to find out the MAC address and then very easy to talk to the central server and tell it to send messages to whatever device. (It's a little like an open relay mail server, and bad for similar reasons)
- gargravarr 10y agoOne other issue is that MAC addresses are allocated in contiguous blocks to manufacturers. If you know the general pattern (the first N characters are manufacturer-specific), there is precious little stopping you writing a script to loop through all the possibilities and spam the server with them. Most network devices have the MAC address printed on a label (with a barcode for an admin to scan), so it would be trivial to grab an example from a photo.
- gargravarr 10y agoWhilst I wouldn't use the word 'devastating', this is certainly a well-written review pointing out the glaring flaws in this IoT device. It's not devastating because there's enough 4- and 5-star reviews from people who have evidently overlooked these flaws (or who have iPhones or old Android devices that allowed setup to work). This word of caution is likely to get lost among the noise. The author has done a steller job highlighting the awful quality and attention to security of an innocuous IoT device. Granted, a wifi-controlled socket is likely to only power a table lamp or something similar, so anyone brute-forcing the MAC addresses isn't going to do horrendous amounts of damage, but the inability to prevent someone doing this is a clear illustration of the little control the end user has over 'smart' devices. Bottom line: if you can't root it, don't put it on your LAN.
- schlowmo 10y ago> "This word of caution is likely to get lost among the noise." Not any longer ;). I didn't have the stats for helpful-votes on this review before it was posted on HN, but now with over 600 votes it's #1. (How many potential buyers care about is another question...)
- ceejayoz 10y ago> It's not devastating because there's enough 4- and 5-star reviews from people who have evidently overlooked these flaws... You misspelled "been paid by the seller via Fiverr".
- StavrosK 10y agoGreat review, but I'm more excited about the fact that this runs on an ESP8266, presumably controlling a simple relay. This means that I can just open it up, hook it up to my computer and flash my own firmware that will be exactly as secure as I need, all for a rather low price. Hell, maybe they left the FOTA port open and I can give people a small script with a firmware so they can just run that and flash the plug over the wifi network!
- driverdan 10y agoWhy pay $30 for such a device when you can order a similar product direct from China for $5? https://www.itead.cc/sonoff-wifi-wireless-switch.html https://www.itead.cc/sonoff-wifi-wireless-switch.html It has the same configuration problems he mentioned but is easily flashable via FTDI.
- nfriedly 10y agoIncidentally, I reviewed a pre-release version of that device a few months back. I didn't try flashing custom firmware to it though - are there any instructions for that that I could link to from the review? http://www.nfriedly.com/techblog/2015-12-16-itead-sonoff-slampher-review/ http://www.nfriedly.com/techblog/2015-12-16-itead-sonoff-sla...
- StavrosK 10y agoIt looks like you connect 3.3V/GND/TX/RX to the four pins shown in this image: http://dl.itead.cc/IM151116002/sonoff-parts-without-433.jpg http://dl.itead.cc/IM151116002/sonoff-parts-without-433.jpg Then you flash it with PlatformIO as usual, except I'm not sure which pins are connected where, that would take some fiddling. I'll buy one to experiment with.
- StavrosK 10y agoOoooh, fantastic! Do you know where to connect the FTDI? I see that they're using a bare ESP8266 instead of a 12E. EDIT: Looks like they even expose serial connection pins. It should be pretty easy to figure out which pin the relay is on and which the button is on.
- hbogert 10y agoparaphrase> The plug connects to a Chinese IP. It's time we setup a standard so that everybody can choose there own "cloud" server for these "smart" home electronics. These manufacturers should not be building their own. Of course the app on your phone could also just connect to the bloody thing itself instead of using these relay servers of the manufacturer. (yes I know, NAT punching is a PITA, but better than this)
- forbiddenlake 10y agoYou can use a solution like Home Assistant or OpenHAB today. Device support isn't 100% there but they are constantly improving.
- martey 10y agoJust as worrisome as the content of the review is the fact that the company tried multiple avenues to make him remove it: https://twitter.com/mjg59/status/747612713786847232 https://twitter.com/mjg59/status/747612713786847232 > Incidentally, now up to three separate emails begging me to remove [the review] or they'll be fired https://twitter.com/mjg59/status/747866725945737216 https://twitter.com/mjg59/status/747866725945737216 contains a screenshot of an email complaining that the review is "unfair" because it is negative and people are marking it as helpful, making it more difficult for other "honest reviewers" to get traction.
- krmmalik 10y agoAbout two months ago i tried out some ads automation software. The concept was good, the product was ok, but support was awful and things were buggy. So i waited patiently until one day i got fed up and made my thoughts public in a tweet. I was civil about it. Anyway within a couple of hours the CEO contacts me telling me how he's been ill in hospital and that half his tech team have left and how he might be shutting the company down, but i could a "please remove the tweet of you blasting us". I felt sorry for him so obliged. 2 months later, they've continued to market the product heavily so he was obviously lying just to get me to remove the tweet. After that experience, im never going back on what I say ever again.
- CWuestefeld 10y agoAt the first link, I'm immediately turned off by his follow-up: Capitalism is fucking bullshit What's really ironic is that this experience shows how well capitalism does work, more effectively than other systems can: The reviewer found a bad product, reviewed it honestly, and is now helping other people stay away from it. Let's see you try to make that happen when you're faced with poor and disinterested government-provided services.
- themgt 10y agoHe doesn't actually clarify his line of thinking. As someone who is also not much a fan of capitalism, my thought at getting those emails might be "this company cut corners trying to turn a quick profit making a crap product, and now some poor shmucks at the bottom are getting fired. capitalism sucks" Soviet-style five year plans are also not the only alternative to hobbesian capitalism, that is a false dichotomy.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y ago> In summary: by default this is stupendously insecure, there's no reasonable way to make it secure That's an honest review? I tend to ignore reviewers who talk about security as an all or nothing proposition. Maybe everyone else will in a few years too.
- anonymousab 10y agoIt is likely possible to take the device apart and overwrite its firmware in some way to be more safe, but that is somewhat unfeasible for the average consumer.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 10y agoI'm not interested in a review of the average consumer and what they can and can't achieve. That seems like a harder problem anyway.
- ljk 10y agothis is a big problem with customer reviews in general. Only rarely you'll see a review by someone who knows what they're doing; most times the reviews are very superficial and isn't helpful at all.