9 ms·
Zenefits Loses Over Half of Its Value
- gatsby 10y agoAmazing that repricings like this are so rare that even investors like A16Z never / rarely see it: >>“This is a unique situation, we’ve never seen it before and we don’t expect to see it again,” said a spokesperson for Andreessen Horowitz. What's the advantage for the company? The article makes it seem like this was David Sacks' decision and he's trying to coerce existing investors into signing off on this "new deal," making it even more strange.
- 55555 10y agoYeah I don't get it. Is the company offering investors more equity in order to prevent a lawsuit for failing to disclose the shady stuff they were doing?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- borski 10y agoYes. That is precisely what is happening.
- rlucas 10y agoSaying "even investors like A16Z" haven't seen it glosses over that A16Z, founded in 2009, is a babe in the woods as a venture firm, and has not been through even a single cycle yet. (Not ragging on them, but lots of these things go in cycles of 8-12 years or more and if your firm is 7 years old you may well have never seen the tough times. And as Buffett likes to say, it's only when the tide goes out that you see who's been swimming without trunks)
- embiggen 10y agoNot a huge surprise given the events of late, especially considering they laid off more than a hundred of their employees. If this is the public slash they are announcing, how bad do you think reality is looking on the inside? Just imagine the spin masters trying to spin this to their employees. I can't help but chuckle a little. Kids. That being said, I'll add that there are certainly aspects of this that are not funny at all. Real people lost their jobs due to the tomfoolery of others. I feel for them. edit Are you saying that all 100 people got the generous severance package?
- foota 10y agoAt the end of the article it states that they offered their employees a chance to leave if they wanted with a generous severance package and that 10% took it. Doesn't sound like they forced them to leave.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- rhizome 10y agoIt's only generous in dotcom terms. My mom took an early-retirement package from Kaiser Permanente as a bog-standard phone-room nurse: free no-copay health insurance for the rest of her and my dad's life. Free treatment, free prescriptions, free equipment. Free everything, for life.
- toomuchtodo 10y agoThat's incredible. Kudos for her taking that deal.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- vecter 10y agoThat's a great deal for your mom, I'm glad she was able to get such an amazing deal. On the other hand, Zenefits is an unprofitable startup with huge internal problems. Clearly, expecting them to provide such sorts of benefits would be beyond unreasonable.
- zaroth 10y agoCan't imagine this is legal. It sounds like they are trying to dilute out Conrad specifically by significantly repricing the earlier rounds and then covering existing employees with new grants. Anyone out of the good graces of the current management sees massive dilution and everyone else is untouched. How is this not just stealing Conrad's shares? The extra kicker is investors signing up for the free shares agree to waive all claims... except against Conrad. Wow, that's vengeful!
- JonFish85 10y agoThat's kind of the point of shares, isn't it? They're super manipulatable and for just this reason: you can get rid of people you don't like. They can fight in court all they want, but a private company will probably win.
- nostrademons 10y agoFWIW, this reminds me a lot of the Facebook/Saverin case. Saverin eventually won back many of his shares; enough that he's worth about $7B now. (And then renounced his American citizenship to avoid paying taxes on it, go figure.) It's a little different in that there may have been misrepresentations about Zenefits' fiscal health to the investors and actual illegal wrongdoing, while in Saverin's case, Facebook just felt that they could do better.
- muzz 10y agoDidn't Eduardo sell his shares in the ~$20 (or even high teens) range?
- nostrademons 10y agoWikipedia says he still holds on to about 50M of them.
- muzz 10y agoThat's how many shares he had at the time of the IPO. They underlying source is correct for its time (2012), but whoever wrote the Wikipedia is misrepresenting it as being from 2015.
- SwellJoe 10y agoDespite all the turmoil around the company, I've been using them for payroll and looking into more HR stuff through them, and it works really well. Much better than Intuit, certainly (which has cost me a fortune in late filing fees and other stuff, because they don't automate tons of stuff that ought to be automated and invisible to the end user, and I suck at doing taxes). I'm surprised they need 900 employees to do what they do, though. But, I guess a huge part of their business is interacting with decrepit old systems used by insurers and states, and often require humans and fax machines and other such nonsense. This is a pretty astounding turn of events; it's not something I've ever even heard of happening. It's certainly better than exploding under the pressure of investor lawsuits, I guess. But, aren't their still regulatory issues being investigated and so catastrophe is still possible?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- 59nadir 10y ago> But, I guess a huge part of their business is interacting with decrepit old systems used by insurers and states, and often require humans and fax machines and other such nonsense. Well, a huge part of their business was to have hordes of people selling stuff faster than they could get people to that point legitimately. Presumably, the hordes are still employed. As a general point, as a consumer you can have a great time using a product no matter how many laws they break along the way, of course. My general counter-reaction to the romanticizing of "disruption" at HN is that I hope they get stuck with massive fines that drive them down to the ground. They could've had a good product and followed the rules.
- harryh 10y agoIt's worth noting that the rules in question here were specifically designed to protect incumbents from competition. It was very clear regulatory capture.
- vroombaprime 10y ago
- iaw 10y ago>> “This is a unique situation, we’ve never seen it before and we don’t expect to see it again,” said a spokesperson for Andreessen Horowitz. This is the golden line in the article, with the "bend the rules" mantra VC's have for their founders I suspect we'll be seeing more of these come to light in the future. Thinking this to be an isolated incident could be very wishful thinking. Even if AH expects every Unicorn to go through a similar event in the near future they wouldn't say as much to the press, there is no benefit for them as VC fund.
- x0x0 10y agoThis may be isolated in the sense of how very clearly against the law/regulations the behavior was, and some of those laws/regulations appear to have teeth if regulators wish them to.
- grellas 10y agoThe repricing is, in effect, a form of settlement agreement with the company's preferred stock investors. What the former CEO did amounted to a form of fraud on the investors. They thought they were investing in a company they thought was worth x but whose real value was less than half the value of x. The company had actual or constructive knowledge of the facts underlying the fraud, to wit, that there was in place an automated program that facilitated and attempted to cover over blatant regulatory violations. This was a material fact known to the then CEO and the company, legally speaking, is charged with his knowledge. Therefore, it constructively knew the truth as well and failed to disclose it to investors when they invested in the prior round (Series C). Since this was highly material to their investment, the sale of securities to such investors without such disclosure amounted to securities fraud. Now, when something like this has happened, people can sometimes let it slide but the impact here was huge and the investors have easily lost at least half the value of their investment. So what does new management do? With the historic problem cleaned up, it reprices the shares in the previous round to set the valuation at the level it should have been (or least much closer to it) had all facts been known and disclosed to investors. This is speaking hypothetically, of course, because investors of this type do not invest in a company that is committing serious legal wrongs and they would not have actually invested here had they known all the facts at the time of their original investment. But, given that the damage had already been done, the proposal made to investors gives them the chance after-the-fact to affirm their investment, release their legal claims, and take the hypothetical value that presumably would have more accurately reflected the real value of the company at the time of their investment had all facts been known and disclosed to them. Is this a perfect solution? No, of course it cannot be. This is a real mess and the wrongs committed were serious. But it gives investors a path through repricing to get more than double the shares they had bought at the prior pricing. The trade-off: they must release all legal claims against the company. Now the carve-outs: if any given investor sees this as an imperfect solution, they can always just say no and file suit against all parties, including the company; and, even for investors who take the deal, there is no absolving of the former CEO in that the release of claims does not extend to him - hence, they reserve all rights to sue him if they like. On top of all this, employees are given RSUs that help minimize the effect of the dilution that is built into this for the benefit of investors. Again, not perfect but another indicator that this has been carefully thought out. If the company revives and its stock value goes up, the employees will essentially be paid bonuses via the RSUs to help make up the difference. This is actually a pretty elegant attempt to salvage what must have been seen by many as a situation beyond repair, first (and formally), by setting up a mechanism to prevent the company from being swamped by lawsuits and, second (and much more importantly) by taking a good faith (and, for the company, painful) step in order to save its relations with its key investors. People should not flippantly dismiss this action just because it is unusual. It may wind up being right or it may wind up being wrong but it clearly is a carefully thought-out attempt to deal with an exceedingly difficult set of circumstances in a creative and constructive way. If it does work, it will be because the investors perceive the business model of the company as fundamentally sound in spite of the earlier illegality and corner-cutting. It is their opportunity to register a vote of confidence for new management to give it another try, this time with an honest respect for the relevant regulatory environment even as the company attempts to disrupt its target market. Whether it works or not, only time will tell.
- encoderer 10y agoI think we'll find David Sacks is going preserve his blue chip reputation by leading the crippled Zenefits into the safe harbor of a rich insurance conglomerate or PE firm. Getting these investors paid out would be the ultimate amends.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kriro 10y agoSo employees get roughly 25% extra shares (RSUs, vesting in 12 month) and the C series investors get >50%? Just out of curiosity, could the employees sue (and are they also releasing their legal claims if they accept the deal)? The same logic of fraud applies to employees. The argument would be that they were thinking the company is doing more amazing that it actually is doing and thus "wasted" time of their life working there under false assumptions. Why do they get a worse deal?
- jessedhillon 10y agoBecause their losses are denominated in time and opportunity, which are more difficult to assess than money.
- driverdan 10y agoTheir existing options are also losing half their value.
- HappyTypist 10y agoAlmost. RSUs have no strike price, so it's better than options.
- againstgreed 10y agoThe hard truth is it's not about the legal problem in Zenefits. Zenefits is not growing from last October. ARR remains the same 60M for last 10 months. If the company is not growing and it's burning more cash than revenue (way more in Zenefits case), the company should be valued at (cash in hand + ARR) which is 700M. No idea how Zenefits still gets 2B valuation.
- brianwawok 10y ago> If the company is not growing and it's burning more cash than revenue, the company should be valued at (cash in hand + ARR) Is that really true? Maybe if a company had NO HOPE of growing. Zenefits has clearly shown some huge growth. The market is huge. Just being not profitable and not growing for the short term does not mean you are guaranteed dead... just that you are default dead and need to get working on it, which they seem to be. Edit - and if truly a company was never going to grow again, I would value them at something like cash on hand + ((total rev - min expenses to stay afloat) * 3) or something... In your example if someone had ARR of 100 million, min expenses to keep doors open of 300 million, and cash on hand of 1 million.. you would value them at 101 million, I would value them at - 599 million.