4 ms·
> more maintainable I get that the Erlang VM is really nice for some things (I made my first contribution to it in 2004!), but I'm curious about the above stat
by davidw 10y ago
> more maintainable
I get that the Erlang VM is really nice for some things (I made my first contribution to it in 2004!), but I'm curious about the above statement, as I haven't had the time to dig into Elixir/Phoenix yet.
- dmix 10y agoI find working with functional languages and type systems (w/ dialyzer in this case) makes my projects more maintainable in general. Might just be a personal bias towards them though. Note: I haven't used Phoenix but I'm a fan of Erlang.
- rozap 10y agoI think most folks are finding that distribution in an erlang based application is a lot simpler, because you don't need to pull in things like redis for pubsub, memcached for caching, etc etc. erlang solves a bunch of problems in a rather elegant way that are solved in the java/python/ruby world through gobs of duct tape.
- davidw 10y agoGood point, but I'd see the actual codebase on a single node as the most important thing for most people. Even with Rails you can do a lot with one server.
- Scarbutt 10y agoPerformance wise, I wouldn't put Java next to ruby and python, in what workload would the erlang vm beat the jvm?
- rozap 10y agoI'm talking more about concurrency and distribution models, not raw performance.
- felixgallo 10y agolow jitter, low latency, high concurrency workloads.
- bcardarella 10y agoThis is mostly an observation I've had of imperative programming vs functional programming. Going back and creating the state of the application in my head is easier when I don't have to find out what else the code is affecting.
- bratsche 10y agoI'm still fairly new with Elixir/Phoenix (as I think most of us still are), but so far I feel intuitively that it's more maintainable and I admit that I don't have the experience or numbers to back that up yet. There are some things that you simply must use other tools for in Rails, because it can't maintain state like Erlang can. Once you start adding in these other things, you're no longer just a "Rails app" but you're really creating an entire system. Now you've got different things you potentially need to test, and you're adding in extra stuff to your system to monitor and measure the different parts of your system. You might do the same thing in Erlang/Elixir, but you also might not. You can potentially keep your entire "system" inside Erlang, either in one node or distributed. So right away simply having that option sounds like a huge improvement in maintainability. You've got everything running in Erlang, monitored and supervised in Erlang/Elixir, more easily testable using ExUnit or whatever. And I think @bcardella talked about this in his RailsConf presentation (linked somewhere in the comments here).. but the performance you get from Elixir/Phoenix is potentially a huge improvement in maintenance. How much time have people spent in NewRelic or whatever measuring and tuning their Rails apps, getting the caching and everything working just right? People are writing Phoenix apps with zero caching that are performing better than Rails with caching. When people aren't having to go debug and diagnose these kinds of performance problems they get to work on actual features. Again, some of this is just my intuition on it more than real experience to back it up. I've built a couple apps with Phoenix and I do enjoy it more. They're not big enough for the performance to really matter, but I do feel strongly that they're simpler because I'm keeping everything in Elixir code and not having to use, for example, Sidekiq in order to do anything async.
- davidw 10y agoI would love to see someone take a deep dive into why their Phoenix thing is "so much faster" than with Rails. I mean really look at the whole stack from the VM, to different pieces of the framework like views and DB interaction. Erlang definitely does concurrency well, but it is not that much faster than Ruby in terms of "raw speed". I'd be fascinated to see someone actually do the work and look at where Phoenix is eking out those gains.
- 10y ago