5 ms·
The autopilot doesn't drive the car, the driver does. The autopilot is a help just like cruise control. Tesla are very clear (apart from the naming of the featu
by alkonaut 10y ago
The autopilot doesn't drive the car, the driver does. The autopilot is a help just like cruise control. Tesla are very clear (apart from the naming of the feature) that the driver must still drive the car.
The autopilot will avoid obstacles it can detect and the driver is expected to avoid others (since he has eyes on the wheel and eyes on the road the whole time).
I think they misleading thing about Teslas Autopilot I its current state is that they call it "Autopilot" while other manufacturers call this kind of assist features e.g "Lane Assist".
A distance-sensing cruise control can't be trusted not to crash into the back of the vehicle in front either, not least because it can't be sure it can "see" it. I suspect motorcycles and other small vehicles may fool radars just like this case seems to have been about contrast and colors in a camera sensor.
- twinkletwinkle 10y ago>The autopilot will avoid obstacles it can detect and the driver is expected to avoid others I'm sorry, how is that supposed to work, exactly? How does the driver know? Sounds like the driver has to avoid every obstacle - to avoid the case where the autopilot fucks you, like this one - and in that case, what is the autopilot doing?
- alkonaut 10y agoThe driver has to be aware of every obstacle and observe the autopilot avoid them, or intervene should it fail. Yes. Have you driven a car with a distance-keeping cruise control? It's very comfortable to let it do that and just watch it and take over when it fails (it's limited in the braking and acceleration it is allowed to do). I can't take my eyes of the road or my hands off the wheel for even a second but it's still useful because it removes all the micromanagement of throttle and brake and just lets me supervise.
- Nadya 10y agoThat is a massive assumption to be making. That the driver can see and react to every obstacle. Not to mention there are videos where the Tesla reacted before and on behalf of the driver, saving them from an accident. The "lane assist" (what it should be and is called by other manufacturers) spots any number of obstacles that the driver failed to see - takes over - and saves the driver from an accident. Or reacts faster than the driver could react - thus saving the driver. That is what it is doing. It is not driving your vehicle. It is assisting in driving your vehicle. It is still possible to drown with a life vest on. That doesn't mean you shouldn't wear one because "if I'm expected to stay above water - what is the life vest doing?"
- mdorazio 10y agoThat's some PR firm-level explaining. First, autopilot is not just lane assist, it's lane assist + adaptive cruise control + additional features (it can change lanes if you tell it to). Other OEMs have purposely shied away from enabling an autopilot-like feature set together, even though it's technically possible, because they are absolutely terrified of something exactly like this situation happening. Second, you're completely ignoring that autopilot will very much entirely drive the car by itself for minutes at a time (reports are anywhere from 5 to 15 depending on software version), which will obviously encourage drivers to not pay attention to the road. I don't care about disclaimers, I don't care about nag screens or chimes, and I definitely don't care about some warranty text that flashes on the screen. If you make a car that can drive itself you encourage drivers to let it do just that and you should be prepared for that eventuality. Period.
- Retra 10y agoThis autopilot is very new and fairly experimental technology. You're basically demanding that this not be true somehow.
- ceejayoz 10y agoVery new and fairly experimental technology that can kill you tends to be fairly heavily regulated. New drugs, rockets, aircraft, etc. don't generally get released via software update to the general public. They go through very regimented, restricted, contracted trials. Tesla risks getting regulators to crack down on new car features across the entire industry if they're not careful.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 10y agoMuch like if you make a car that does 0-60mph in 3 seconds or does 200mph you encourage doing that. The fact that the autopilot is so good that it "almost" works as a driver is an issue for Tesla as we can see here. I realize autopilot has a nice ring to it, but it's not a chauffeur... Tesla sure has balls to pick the name "Autopilot" when it really should be called "CoPilot" and that would have saved a lot of trouble.
- npizzolato 10y ago> The autopilot doesn't drive the car, the driver does. The autopilot is a help just like cruise control. Tesla are very clear (apart from the naming of the feature) that the driver must still drive the car. I'm sorry, but that's a cop-out. What's the point of an autopilot if you have to avoid every single obstacle and react to every single thing as if the auto-pilot didn't exist? You can't say "autopilot is safer than normal humans" (heavily implied by the blog post) and then turn around and say "but it's really the driver who's responsible for everything!" anytime there's an accident. Unlike autopilot, cruise control has very limited functionality. No driver expects it to do anything other than keep their speed, so they are still actively engaged with the road to respond to anything that takes place.
- alkonaut 10y ago> I'm sorry, but that's a cop-out. What's the point of an autopilot if you have to avoid every single obstacle and react to every single thing as if the auto-pilot didn't exist? You don't have to react - you have to supervise it though. It lets the driver monitor a system that micromanages steering, brakes and throttle, instead of doing that micromanagement himself. It requires the same attention but is less work. > Unlike autopilot, cruise control has very limited functionality. No driver expects it to do anything other than keep their speed, Well, these days you can often set it with a distance to the car in front using a radar. You then let the cruise control do something more than just keep constant speed, it will slow down if the car in front does etc. The driver has to pay full attention though for anything the cruise control can't handle. You seem to imply "what's the point of an autopilot if I can't take a nap". - well the issue is that it's a little too good to be called a cruise control, but not good enough for a nap. We're simply not there quite yet. At least not legally.
- macintux 10y agoThe problem to me seems to be: at highway speeds, you have to decide very quickly whether or not it's something that the system can't handle. If you're constantly responding to every change in conditions, what's the point of the autopilot? So you don't respond every time, and then something comes up that the autopilot doesn't recognize, and you don't know that until it's too late.