3 ms·
> I do know quite a bit about physics. But if I just said the EmDrive is nonsense due to conservation of momentum (which is the 100% correct answer with no cave
by tzs 10y ago
> I do know quite a bit about physics. But if I just said the EmDrive is nonsense due to conservation of momentum (which is the 100% correct answer with no caveats), people would shut me down because "NASA scientists know what they're doing".
I wouldn't. However, I would ask why you think violation of conservation of momentum is completely dispositive, rather than just a strong reason for great skepticism?
From Noether's Theorem [1] we know that conservation of momentum is a consequence of physics being invariant under space translation. As far as I've been able to find, we don't know that a universe that results from a big bang must be isotropic. Observationally, ours appears to be, but there are some hints that it might not be, and scientists are taking those seriously.
[1] http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/noether.html http://math.ucr.edu/home/baez/noether.html