4 ms·
That's not necessarily the case. Silverlight runs on top of IE6. Silverlight 3 has support for "plugable media codecs", which means that you can stream Theora/
by bad_user 17y ago
That's not necessarily the case.
Silverlight runs on top of IE6. Silverlight 3 has support for "plugable media codecs", which means that you can stream Theora/OGG content in Silverlight (I don't know if it can be hardware accelerated ... but it would work for non-HD content anyway).
Silverlight also has good browser/JS interoperability, which means it is possible to add support for HTML5 Theora in any IExplorer version without even asking the user if it wants to or not.
I couldn't find better references, but see here ...
http://www.atoker.com/blog/2010/02/04/html5-theora-video-codec-for-silverlight/ http://www.atoker.com/blog/2010/02/04/html5-theora-video-cod...
http://tirania.org/blog/archive/2009/Mar-23-1.html http://tirania.org/blog/archive/2009/Mar-23-1.html
Penetration is already pretty good, and I'm pretty sure that within the next 2 years all IExplorer users will have Silverlight installed (Microsoft can always push it using their update mechanism).
You could do the same in Firefox ... add support for H.264 by using a Flash or a Silverlight applet in combination with a JS script that manipulates the HTML5 tags and communicates with the applet.
Since Silverlight is also running in Safari, you can add Theora support to it too (wouldn't work for iPhones, but still, it's pretty cool).
And it's all transparent. No confirmation dialogs.
It all depends on penetration rate of Silverlight of course, but recent stats (from riastats.com or statowl.com) puts it at ~ 45% ... jumping 10% from September (probably because of events like the Vancouver Olympics requiring it).
So web developers that are looking for a solution to streaming media that's standards compliant, can just do something like this.
Pretty ironic that the technical solution for this new format war comes from Microsoft.
- DrJokepu 17y agoYou can't really stream Vorbis in Silverlight 3. Yes, you can plug in codecs, but there aren't any usable codec plugins available. There's one made by Mono that is way too buggy to be used in production and another one that's not even released yet, just promised in a blog post so might be just as well vaporware. I'm not sure if there's anything for Theora at all and I don't think there ever will be, considering that Silverlight can legally play back H264 out of the box anyway and anyone who does stuff in Silverlight (and generally Microsoft stack) is probably a pragmatist and not an ideologist who worries about the "freeness" of codecs.
- bad_user 17y agoIt's not there yet, but it is technically possible. Of course the current implementation sucks, because it's an abandoned port of some Java code. But if someone cares enough about this, it can be implemented. And you wouldn't need to be someone that does stuff in Silverlight ... all is needed is some Javascript/applet stored on some CDN that you can just drop in your HTML. As far as ideologists go (thinking about services like Wikimedia here) ... what's better? Using a proprietary plugin for those proprietary platforms that don't have Theora or using a patented format? Life is full of compromises, you can't have it all.