3 ms·
You got that wrong. It is not about winning wars. Hitler also did not care about the wars. They were tools for him. Tools in the struggle of the 'germanic race'
by lispm 17y ago
You got that wrong. It is not about winning wars. Hitler also did not care about the wars. They were tools for him. Tools in the struggle of the 'germanic race' over all other races. If the Germans do not win the war, they were not worthy in his view as 'race' to survive. Hitler was motivated by racism and race struggle.
We should have learned from these mistakes. These are not how things should be done. We should not repeat the mistakes of the past.
- philwelch 17y agoWhat part did I get wrong? I'm not making any moral statements, just synthesizing some facts. It largely wasn't until after Hitler lost that the Western world really cared about condemning genocide. I live in a country that was built through conquest by defeating its original inhabitants in war and either enslaving them, relocating them, or exterminating them so the conquerers could inhabit their land. I suspect a lot of us are, and we don't all live in the same country. That's how a frightening amount of history unfolded--and if you're alive today, there's a pretty decent chance your ancestors won one of those wars. Hitler's conquest of Europe differed only in his methods. Again, I'm not making any moral judgments. It seems to me that centuries of history were made by some groups violently enslaving, relocating, or exterminating other groups, and no one really cared that much. Hitler, like most conquerers, thought it was perfectly fine to enslave, relocate, or exterminate other groups of people as long as it served the interests of his own. His philosophy wasn't unique in that respect, in historical terms it was probably the norm. You and I are enlightened enough that we don't want to "repeat" those "mistakes", but only because Hitler was famously unpopular and lost the war. If Hitler cut a deal with the western Allies and satisfied himself with a large chunk of eastern Europe, I don't know how many of us would share the enlightened anti-Nazi attitude we do share.
- lispm 17y agoThis part: Hitler would never have been satisfied with a partial victory, so the whole assumption is wrong. The victory also would not look like the Germans won over France in the second world war or the allied forces won over Germany. Hitler wasted no time. When he came into power he soon killed his opposition, put them into labor camps or, later, send them to the front of the war. As soon as he got into power he started to go after the jews. As soon as he conquered Poland, they started the killing and when the front of war moved on, behind that they installed the concentration camp to get rid of disabled people, prostitutes, communists, priests, homosexuals, jews, ... Either they were killed immediately or, the stronger, were put to work - they were killed through working under extreme situations. They were enslaved. Hitler and Nazi Germany installed a system to get these people and to bring them to the concentration camps. Hitler also was not more unpopular after Germany lost the war. It took two generations to get rid of that. Children or grand children who questioned the doings and motives of their fathers and grand fathers. It took a lot of discussions, research, documentation to understand what happened and why. This understanding did not happen over night and not because Hitler won the war. But because people found out that there were millions of dead people, there were jews that were missing, where were they? The children asked their parents and they were not satisfied with the answers. What did the German army do in Russia? Research was needed to go to the truth and it was ugly. Again: Hitler did not want to win some war and some partial victory. He was talking about the 'Endsieg': the final victory. You are making an assumption that is not in line with Hitler's goals. He would not have been satisfied with anything less then the Endsieg. Hitler was no rational politician - he was a racist and mass murderer. There is also nothing positive to say about Stalin and all the other criminals from the past. That there were more like Hitler does not make him 'relatively bad'. He was bad. Period. 'What if Hitler did this or that?' is plain wrong if you don't understand his motives, his deep hate of other 'unworthy' races, etc. A compromise - that would be either tactics (like history shows his compromises were) or not Hitler.
- philwelch 17y ago"Again: Hitler did not want to win some war and some partial victory. He was talking about the 'Endsieg': the final victory." Yes--German domination over the entirety of Europe. He bit off more than he could chew, though. If he hadn't allied with Japan and made a few strategic decisions better than he had, Germany would still have most of Europe today. That's not my point, though. My point is that, had Hitler been a successful conquerer, he wouldn't be nearly as hated as he is. Maybe that success would have involved slightly less ambition (but the same amount of genocide). As far as the brutality and genocide go, the main difference is that Hitler was so damned good at it. If you want to kill off 10 million people, it's far more cost-effective to enslave them and work them to death, isn't it? On the other hand, consider the white domination of North America. The Indians were set against one another in various wars. If a tribe or band was defeated they were either exterminated or forcibly relocated to reservations. Treaties were repeatedly signed and broken--if we relocated a group of Indians to a piece of land that ended up being valuable, we relocated them again. We weren't organized enough to set up concentration camps, but we had enough room we could give them parcels of worthless land for reservations. If we didn't enslave them directly, we bought slaves from Indian slavers, which only led them to more warfare, so the winners could sell the losers as slaves. Incidentally, this is also how white people ruined West Africa. Once white people achieved their "manifest destiny" over North America, they really didn't seem to care too much about all the genocide and mass murder and racism involved. Even today, a lot of them don't. Incidentally, the German people turned against Hitler as soon as he started losing. I don't know that they really cared much about the genocide yet, but they were mad at Hitler because it was Hitler's fault that allied bombs were landing on their houses. If Hitler won, no one would have really questioned or cared what he did to get there, or why there was suddenly so much room in what used to be Eastern Europe for them to move out into. "Hitler was no rational politician - he was a racist and mass murderer." You keep acting like this is any kind of unique distinction among imperialists and conquerers throughout history.