5 ms·
I would expect google to keep all financial documents inside Google Drive. In doing so, I wonder what is left in the office for the Spanish authorities to find
by josephg 10y ago
I would expect google to keep all financial documents inside Google Drive. In doing so, I wonder what is left in the office for the Spanish authorities to find in a raid? (Google is ruthlessly paperless internally.)
- Kristine1975 10y ago>Google is ruthlessly paperless internally. Not if they have to keep information on paper to comply with the law.
- ocdtrekkie 10y agoI would also not be surprised to find that some of the financial department sorts of people Google employs are exceedingly old school or ordinary.
- wklauss 10y agoThis is the case. Spansish law requires companies to keep a copy of accounting books and register them periodically. That doesn't mean they have to be in paper form all the time, but they need to produce a copy if requested for tax auditing reasons. The "raid" goal is to prevent tampering of the files during the request.
- rs999gti 10y ago> Not if they have to keep information on paper to comply with the law. This really means print on demand.
- ForHackernews 10y agoGoogle Docs sets browser cookies. If you have a surprise raid with logged-in workstations, you have access to Drive documents as well.
- josu 10y agoJust to give some context, a few years ago the Spanish Police arrested the leaders of Anonymous [1]. As a Spaniard, my opinion is that this is just an intimidatory and political move. [1] http://www.cnet.com/news/spain-says-it-has-arrested-anonymous-hackers/ http://www.cnet.com/news/spain-says-it-has-arrested-anonymou...
- cocotino 10y agoPolitical? There isn't even a government right now.
- feiss 10y agoI agree. They do it the same day they publish a list of the biggest debtors, and 4 days after elections. http://es.reuters.com/article/topNews/idESKCN0ZG1E6 http://es.reuters.com/article/topNews/idESKCN0ZG1E6
- kalleboo 10y ago> after elections Isn't that backwards?
- Bromskloss 10y agoI would love to see a police force bursting in, and smoke immediately starting to rise from every computer. I mean, you could do it it software too, but it would look cool and send a signal to the officers. :-) Or you could keep the door locked.
- cmdrfred 10y agoInteresting idea. Keep the door closed, once opened (reed switch?) Write 0's to memory then pull power to the workstation. Just be sure to save your work before you go to the bathroom.
- Kristine1975 10y agoDestruction of evidence?
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Bromskloss 10y agoMaybe so. If you just want the effect, you could release smoke just for show, without actually destroying anything.
- StavrosK 10y agoYou mean if you want them to think you destroyed the evidence, and thus incurring the wrath of the law, without actually destroying the evidence that might incriminate you? Sounds like a lose-lose scenario, to me.
- tedmiston 10y agoUntil they click "Sign out all other sessions" remotely. I'm not sure if opening a Google Doc from the local file system would work without a connection.
- linkregister 10y agoThat would almost certainly condemn the local employees to face obstruction of justice charges, turning a minor "you have to relocate" issue into "you are imprisoned awaiting a criminal trial" one.
- tedmiston 10y agoI hope this was not mistaken as advice. My intent was merely a point in technical discussion.
- pns 10y agoIf hard drive is encrypted (and like most companies like Google, almost certain they would be), then you wouldn't be able to get much unless you someone got them to disable screensavers/computer sleep and keep the machines on for awhile
- Phlarp 10y agoLaw enforcement has specific tools that do precisely this. Google "USB mouse jigglers" for more info. They also have gear that can splice into the power cord of a live machine without interrupting the flow-- the combination of these two devices allows them to seize unlocked computers and keep them accessible while taking custody of the machine.
- drzaiusapelord 10y agoSpain, and other Euro countries, have "paper" laws. Everything needs to be printed out and stored to make raids like these easier on the government. It also keeps their tax authority from ever having to worry about modernizing and, frankly, makes it easier for the government to manufacture "irregularities." I think the financial crisis in some of these EU countries have reached a point where they are politically paralyzed (can't move to the right due to strong leftism in the electorate) so they'll just find a way to milk multi-nationals to keep the lights on. This isn't a long term strategy and is a sign of some bad stuff coming up. I believe in the long run the welfare state is unaffordable and without a move to the right these countries will suffer, especially as business moves to more tax friendly jurisdictions and leaves these markets over government abuse, low sales, low margins, etc. Currently, Spain has 25% unemployment and almost 50% for those under 25. The GDP is falling at the same rate it is for France and Italy. The sudden interest in these countries to raid multi-nationals for tax reasons is no coincidence here. France just raided Google's office last month. I suspect Italy is next.
- patrickaljord 10y agoNot sure why you're being downvoted. I'm French and totally agree with your views except maybe that right wings here are just as leftist economically so I'm very pessimistic for the future.
- walterstucco 10y agoit's the leftists that are following right wings politics...
- mancerayder 10y agoMilking the multinationals is too bold a statement. Consider that Europe has had austerity in several countries. The average person was told that they needed to suffer fiscally for a few years (in terms of social services being trimmed and taxes not going down, sometimes going up) in order to redress spending imbalances and show the bond markets that things are under control. Meanwhile, we learn that the very largest, cash-rich, profitable companies in the world are paying little tax compared to other companies and small businesses, all because of special tax treatment in some countries. Is it any surprise that politicians have to act on that? This is the connection. And someone below said that the HN forum is far left. That's a little rich, pun intended, given that many of the people who contribute are directly related to venture capital, or own lots of stock or are self employed, or just wealthy. Sometimes the world can't as easily be broken into left and right.
- pyrale 10y agoI'm not sure the solution to google being perceived by states as running tax laundering schemes is to adopt anti-investigation measures.
- CaptSpify 10y agoHow was his question anti-investigation?
- scarecrowbob 10y agoThe question isn't, but being paperless and cloud-based seems like it would make it more difficult to investigate for the folks investigating.
- CaptSpify 10y agoPossibly, but that's not why they are paperless. I'm guessing the goal of going paperless is much less about being anti-investigative, and more about convenience, environment, etc. It just happens to have some aspects that are possibly anti-investigative.
- 0xmohit 10y agoOh no, they apparently keep those documents in the calendar. And they've brought it down! https://www.google.com/appsstatus#hl=en&v=issue&sid=2&iid=847490285bf1b9e082a699bafb95f53b https://www.google.com/appsstatus#hl=en&v=issue&sid=2&iid=84...