6 ms·
How can this still be possible? Shouldn't all tax legislation be such that if you break the spirit of it by having internal transfers (royalties, fees, interest
by alkonaut 10y ago
How can this still be possible? Shouldn't all tax legislation be such that if you break the spirit of it by having internal transfers (royalties, fees, interest) to a low-tax area, then you are still taxed based on the business that you had in the country in question, and not based on the net sum (i.e. zero).
The current state of tax law is that a billion dollar company pays almost no taxes but a million dollar company pays a lot. That can't be good for anyone (apart from the $1B company).
Are countries, simply put, afraid to put an end to tax schemes like this, because it would just mean that Ikea or Google would pack up and leave?
- zo1 10y ago"Are countries, simply put, afraid to put an end to tax schemes like this, because it would just mean that Ikea or Google would pack up and leave?" In an "odd" application of market-competition, that is precisely what happened. Countries where Google generally did business wanted to tax Google at some X. Then along came Ireland, or Google found Ireland, and saw that they could do some legal paperwork and pay Ireland's tax rate of X-Y instead of X in the "source" countries. The point I'm making is that Google did pack up and leave, and it will happen again unless really drastic actions are taken against them. I don't think anyone wants to do that, at this point. You either bully all countries from allowing loop holes such as this, even though they don't want to. Or you disallow Google from operating in your country if they don't pay taxes on the profit from "sales" you deem occurred in your country. Small countries that want/need that tax revenue from Google, even if it is X-Y, won't like it if you compel them into complying and causing Google to "pack up and leave". It also puts the "bullying" nature of whatever international body is tasked with enforcing this into light.
- alkonaut 10y agoSeems like a reasonable thing to decide at international level. We have already more or less forced (or come to an agreement with) Switzerland to not hide "dark money". Getting some stronger wording in the tax legislation on EU level should be doable, but of course the Netherlands would squirm a bit.
- ForHackernews 10y agoIt seems like they should just assess tax liability based on something other than where a company locates its headquarters. Maybe in order to do business in jurisdiction X, where "doing business" == "selling ads" in Google's case, you have to pay taxes to X.
- ptaipale 10y agoThe selling of ads is already taxed. It's called VAT. It's a major revenue source for both EU, and all member nations.
- spriggan3 10y ago> The point I'm making is that Google did pack up and leave No they did not. There is a Google Spain and a Google France. They can't escape the Spanish law or the french law if they have an office in these countries, no matter where Google trully is incorporated, and there is an obvious reason why they have officies in these countries. So what Google Spain and Google France do is that they pay huge fees to Google Ireland for the use of Google brand, so they never make a profit officially, then the money is ex filtrated from Google Ireland to tax havens. But they did not leave Spain nor France.
- aianus 10y agoGoogle Search and Adwords are not developed in Spain or France. In effect these subsidiaries are just local distributors for a US product. If Apple sells an iPhone (developed in the US and built in China) to retailers in Paris, should they have to pay French income tax on the entire profit of the phone? Of course not, that's ridiculous, even if the retailer is an Apple subsidiary.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- varjag 10y ago> Google Search and Adwords are not developed in Spain or France. In effect these subsidiaries are just local distributors for a US product. Neither they are developed in Ireland, but they chose to pay their tax there. Perhaps that's significant.
- anonymousDan 10y ago"Then along came Ireland." This is utter nonsense. The problem is US tax repatriation laws introduced during the Clinton administration that allow US companies to leave their profits offshore in countries such as Bermuda or the Cayman Islands. Since they are only taxable on repatriation to the US, they pay no tax on them. Instead, they pressure Congress to introduce 'one-off' tax amnesties that allow them to repatriate at a much lower rate. This problem could be solved tomorrow if US politicians rescinded those tax laws. Ireland has no legal right to tax those profits, since they are earned by parent US company e.g. Google US. Which is perfectly correct, since the foundation of most of those profits are the intellectual property created primarily by the parent company. Don't let US politicians pull the wool over your eyes that this is a problem over which they have no control. In case you're interested, here's a good article that gives more background: http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/the-biggest-tax-scam-ever-20140827 http://www.rollingstone.com/politics/news/the-biggest-tax-sc...
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoAnd if they paid that tax in the US (which would then allow the US rate to be lower for the same revenue), how would that help Spain and France? The US would just be what Ireland currently is.
- uola 10y ago> (which would then allow the US rate to be lower for the same revenue) While I'm sure it can be minimized, the US doesn't have a particularly low corporate income tax rate. > And if they paid that tax in the US [...] how would that help Spain and France? Companies like Google not having to pay tax on revenues outside the US is essentially a government subsidy. One that creates a "slush fund" for US companies to acquire their European competition. We're essentially in a trade war, just that Europe hasn't realized it.
- anonymousDan 10y agoExactly! Basically US companies have a massive tax advantage over local competitors in other countries. Every time you see another local bookshop closing down because it can't compete with Amazon's 'economies of scale', you should realise in fact a large part of its advantages are due to US tax repatriation laws.
- tobias3 10y agoJust yesterday they put a whistleblower which published such tax evasion schemes in connection with Luxembourg into prison (LuxLeaks). They ruled that illegal state aid, because the Luxembourg tax authorities actively helped the companies setting up this scheme. The then prime minister and ex-finance minister of Luxembourg Jean-Claude Juncker is now EU Commision president. So either he is incompetent and did not know about this, or he was involved. He claims he is only incompetent. With the EU leadership being corrupt or incometent, it is no wonder the big companies are dancing circles around the national tax authorities.
- kuschku 10y ago> With the EU leadership being corrupt or incometent, it is no wonder the big companies are dancing circles around the national tax authorities. Well, it’s more like the EU can not do anything while the national authorities can veto them, and the national authorities still have the competence for that, and the right-populists in the EU are proposing even less power for the EU authorities.
- tobias3 10y agoYes, indeed. And now Juncker is trying to pass CETA without national parliaments and that is currently backfiring, too. There was this moment during the crisis where I think we could have moved forward with EU bonds, a proper banking union, increased EU budged and debt relief for Greece. But now we are stuck with a deteriorating status quo. I blame Merkel for lack of leadership but maybe she just knows the limits of what she can push through.
- saalweachter 10y agoThere's also the huge "problem" that the countries in the EU want to maintain sovereignty. France and Spain can't really stop Ireland from doing whatever the hell it wants without giving up some of their own sovereignty. In the United States, one of the biggest powers of the Federal government is its power to regulate interstate commerce. No one in the EU is willing to give it so much authority.
- charlesdm 10y agoA royalty, by default, is still payment for something. Take two identical cars, one with the Audi brand, and one without. What's the brand value now then? You should be able to deduct a part of your profit if said IP is held in a lower tax jurisdiction, which will almost always be the case, since multinationals have bases in many different countries.
- AnthonyMouse 10y ago> How can this still be possible? Shouldn't all tax legislation be such that if you break the spirit of it by having internal transfers (royalties, fees, interest) to a low-tax area, then you are still taxed based on the business that you had in the country in question, and based on the net sum (i.e. zero). How would that even work? The costs are actually costs. Imagine it was actually a dozen different companies. One of them is in California and it develops software on contract, one is in Germany and it develops hardware on contract, one is in China and it manufactures hardware on contract, one is in Ireland and it has the original capital which it pays to the first three in exchange for copyrights, hardware designs and hardware, one is in Spain and it buys product/services from the Irish company and sells local advertising, etc. It turns out the company with that owns the copyrights makes the most money. That's how it honestly works whether the companies are separate or not. If you made the Spanish company liable for taxes on the profits of the whole supply chain, every company in Spain that uses Google ads would owe taxes on the money paid to Google (and the same for anything they buy from anyone). In other words you would have enacted a sales tax. Which is fine, but isn't an income tax and isn't a tax on Google. What you seem to want to do is to identify that the companies are actually owned by the same party and do something different in that case. But five seconds after you require that, they would separate. Specifically the company that exists in a jurisdiction that cares about that would become independent. You don't need to own the stock of a company to capture all of its profits when you're its only viable supplier. So now there is an independent contractor in Spain that pays Google Ireland for ad space and resells it for just enough money to pay its own bills and makes no profits. The problem is fundamentally that income tax makes no sense across borders. People will move whatever it is you're taxing into the country with the lowest taxes if the cost of moving that thing is less than the cost of the taxes. The cost of moving profits is very small. You have to tax something which is harder to move, which is then no longer an income tax.
- moron4hire 10y agoI see no reason they shouldn't be arranged as such separate companies and I think the multinational corporation should be banned.
- 10y ago
- unusximmortalis 10y agohttps://youtu.be/Pn10cEm8X_E https://youtu.be/Pn10cEm8X_E