18 ms·
And this is horrible for the market. A company gaining a huge advantage by getting a total monopoly over another market, which they can enforce due to having p
by kuschku 10y ago
And this is horrible for the market.
A company gaining a huge advantage by getting a total monopoly over another market, which they can enforce due to having patents.
That’s not what patents were supposed to create, and what Antitrust regulations were supposed to prevent.
If this is the future, it’s quite a dystopia: Monopolies everywhere.
Sure, I get that the Silicon Valley business model is to destroy regulation, get a monopoly (ideally in a new market niche, but destroying existing competition with illegal predatory pricing is also common), and then to abuse the monopoly, but is no one thinking that for the average consumer a free, competitive market might be better?
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoThis is my theory as to why Europe can't compete with silicon valley. It turns out, what they're "competing" on is willingness to turn a blind eye to monopolies and their negative economic effects.
- zorked 10y agoAre these effects really negative then?
- lmm 10y agoFor a fixed level of technology, a competitive industry is better for customers than a monopoly industry. But an innovative monopoly may be better than a stagnant competitive industry, and the prospect of monopoly rents encourages innovation. The patent system is supposed to be the compromise here: if you innovate you get 20 years of monopoly, after that your innovation is commoditised.
- adrianN 10y agoIt's not really a competition if the companies don't try to innovate.
- petra 10y agoBut even when with regards to innovative monopolies, the monopoly can lead in the wrong direction. On example is that today because Google monopolizes search, you cannot find a decent forum search engine, which seems terrible from the Democratic perspective.
- ZeroGravitas 10y agoOf course in reality, patents are filed in large numbers by monopolies, and potential competitors are threatened with nuisance lawsuits, into either avoiding competition with incumbents entirely, or paying fees to them. Another area where the US seems happy to let monopolies flourish at the expense of progress and competition.
- forrestthewoods 10y agoEhhh Kiva being the only company isn't a healthy market. Even if they're selling to everyone. To be honest Amazon buying Kiva is probably the best thing that could happen. They broadcast to the world that such a company is worth almost a billion dollars. Now the market is filling with competitors and investment. That's exactly what you want.
- nl 10y agoPatents over physical mechanisms are somewhat defensible IMHO. Generally they really do need to be innovative because physical processes are easier to understand (unlike software) and so they are harder to defend in court. Additionally, from the article it looks like patents were only one reason no one else is as good - it seems more like no one else had tried to build anything like them. Also, Amazon is generally seen as good for consumers - they force down prices like no one else. They might not be that great for warehouse employees though.
- kuschku 10y agoYou do know Amazon is now using your history to find out which products you want, and increase the price shown to you for them, or even lock them behind a Prime requirement? And for the suppliers, it’s also problematic. That’s why usually the solution is a free market.
- brc 10y agoA monopoly is a specific thing, not just an insult to a company you don't like. Most monopolies can only be sustained through state intervention, which is why large government is more of a problem than large companies like Amazon. This situation is fantastic for the consumer - companies competing to lower prices and increase service. As the story says the market has responded quickly and the industry is growing, precisely how things are supposed to work.
- lhopki01 10y agoMonopoly is the natural end state of capitalism. Once a company is big enough it's easy to destroy or buy out all competition. It's only regulation that prevents all industries becoming monopolies over time. You're confusing monopolies coopting government to maintain control with large government causing and maintaining monopolies.
- icebraining 10y agoOnce a company is big enough it's easy to destroy or buy out all competition. Can you provide one single example of this having happened? I'm willing to believe it, I just haven't found one. Typical examples provided fall short of that claim.
- bboreham 10y agoStandard Oil "In 1904, Standard controlled 91 percent of production and 85 percent of final sales." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Oil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_Oil
- joslin01 10y agoYes, and a few sentences later for context: "Due to competition from other firms, their market share had gradually eroded to 70 percent by 1906 which was the year when the antitrust case was filed against Standard, and down to 64 percent by 1911 when Standard was ordered broken up"
- 10y ago
- antisthenes 10y agoProperly regulated monopolies are the most efficient form of a market. In fact it is quite the opposite of what you're imagining.
- kuschku 10y agoI agree. That’s why I usually consider government monopolies as better than for profit companies, as better than private monopolies. (Considering the correlation between government monopolies being usually regulated better). Sadly, in the past decades, we haven’t seen those in many places anymore. The UK has mismanaged the NHS for many years, and is now considering to privatize it into a private monopoly. Look at Comcast, TWC, etc, who have regional monopolies, and how well they work. And considering how easy politicians are to bribe, I am not sure we can get properly regulated monopolies at all anymore. Until we can ensure the proper regulation, we might want to prevent monopolies from even occuring.