3 ms·
Hooray, this is finally starting to get some attention! It really grinds my gears how "voiding your warranty" has become coined as a tinkerer badge of honor, e
by mindslight 10y ago
Hooray, this is finally starting to get some attention!
It really grinds my gears how "voiding your warranty" has become coined as a tinkerer badge of honor, even though one is doing no such thing. In the case of something with GPL components like Android, some modification is even expressly granted!
Having said that, the stickers themselves aren't illegal. They fall under a backwards legal principle that adversaries can purposely mislead you without consequence.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> Having said that, the stickers themselves aren't illegal. They fall under a backwards legal principle that adversaries can purposely mislead you without consequence. Except, as the article (and the FTC official quoted therein) states, the law in question (the Magnusson-Moss Warranty Act) actually does prohibits various deceptive implications which the stickers can reasonably be viewed as conveying.
- mindslight 10y agoI do now see the relevant clauses of the Act, and see how they could imply as such (although said sticker isn't actually referencing any brand). But obviously lawyers from most major electronics companies seem to disagree, at least in expected value terms.
- gizmo686 10y ago>In the case of something with GPL components like Android, some modification is even expressly granted! Is it? My understanding is that GPLv2 only requires that the source code be available, not that the user can replace the software on their device. GPLv3 does have some "anti-tivoization" protections, but I am not aware of it going so far as to provide require warrenties to be extended to modified versions.
- mindslight 10y ago> You may modify your copy or copies of the Program or any portion of it The copy of the program is residing on flash memory, so modification of those bits is expressly allowed. What the GPL2 is lacking is any explicit guarantee that the final system will execute that modified code (although I personally think any signing keys fall under "installation scripts", and wish some Linux contributors would step up to the plate).
- dragonwriter 10y ago> In the case of something with GPL components like Android, some modification is even expressly granted! The GPL granting permission to make the change (so that it is not creating an unauthorized derivative work in violation of copyright) does not guarantee that doing so does not void your warranty to the extent that the law of the applicable jurisdiction allows manufacturers to set conditions for voiding warranties.