10 ms·
Today’s Renters Are Worse Off Than Their Parents
- notadoc 10y agoWell yes, this is obvious. Nobody today is buying ranch houses in Palo Alto for $160,000 anymore.
- turnip1979 10y agoMy hypothesis is that people without significant real assets are all worse off since the money supply has been debased. Peter Thiel's book talks about "secrets" that are not really hidden but overlooked .. if he were to interview me and ask what I thought was an apparent secret, I'd say it was this. I'm not even sure what one can do if one accepts this .. borrow money and hoard real assets? If you don't have money to begin with, how do you get the loans? So yeah .. defn worse off.
- justinlardinois 10y agoI'm curious about what you're saying, but I'm a little confused by your terminology. Are you using "debased" here to refer to inflation? And could you elaborate on Thiel's definition of "secrets" and what exactly the "secret" here is?
- dragonwriter 10y ago> My hypothesis is that people without significant real assets are all worse off since the money supply has been debased. "Debased" in this context doesn't make any sense; it really only makes sense in commodity or representational currencies, not fiat money. If you mean "devalued", then you really should say that. But I'm not sure how the logic works, anyway, unless you assume that those without "real" assets also tend to have a constant and positive wealth of fiat currency, such that decline in fiat currency value has the same effect on their net wealth. I really think there is, at most, a coincidence or possibly common cause here rather than the causal link you suggeset, which I don't see any clear rationale or evidence for.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- Spooky23 10y agoWhenever you have inflation, it's always good to have assets, either real property (they're not making more land) or durable goods.
- toodlebunions 10y agoThe Federal Reserve would agree with part of your thesis, as zero interest rates and quantitative easing has caused significant asset inflation and those who are not asset holders have not benefited at all. Instead, many are now priced out of real estate, and have to pay high P/E valuations for stocks. Much higher risk to participate now.
- fspear 10y agoSo what are the viable options for those of us without significant assets? This is a real issue for me at this stage as even though I am a relatively high income earner I have been completely priced out of the real estate market. Rent takes up most of my salary making saving up for a decent deposit really dificult (I live in Australia).
- notadoc 10y agoThe argument I have often heard is that access to credit can be an equalizer. Obviously using credit is high risk at these asset price levels though, but a mortgage is how most average people get to participate in asset inflation.
- gohrt 10y agoOptions from HN: Go to a coding bootcamp, accrue significant assets.
- antisthenes 10y agoRevolution?
- zip1234 10y agoAlso, the size of new homes has risen from 1600 in 1973 to 2600 today. It's not like all factors remain the same. You can drive through old neighborhoods near me with 1000 sq ft houses that sell for $40k because nobody wants a house that small. I'll bet a lot of the homes being built in Palo Alto right now are not small.
- khuey 10y agoThere are very very few homes being built in Palo Alto right now.
- devonkim 10y agoElizabeth Warren addresses this trend in a paper showing most homes' square footage went up to add a second bathroom in comparison to the middle of the century. The cost of labor to add a bathroom and the raw cost of the materials in relation to that low cost house is probably also not worth it either because if we're talking $40k houses I would heavily bet that the property is in an area with no non-minimum wage jobs within reasonable commute distance nor retirees that need income.
- notadoc 10y agoA 1200sq ft 3 bed 1 bath ranch in Palo Alto today costs about $1.8 million, they're all over zillow and sell quick too.
- 0xcde4c3db 10y ago> You can drive through old neighborhoods near me with 1000 sq ft houses that sell for $40k because nobody wants a house that small. How closely have you looked at those $40K houses? I've seen a handful of sub-$100K smaller houses listed in my region, but they're wrecks; they'd need a massive amount of work to get anywhere near the comfort and safety level of a modern, well-maintained house. They're basically the house equivalent of buying a $500 car.
- maxsilver 10y ago> You can drive through old neighborhoods near me with 1000 sq ft houses that sell for $40k because nobody wants a house that small. Sure, but a $40k house will need anywhere from $90k to $160k worth of additional repairs to be safe to inhabit. And since that cost isn't in the equity, most people in most areas can't qualify to finance that. (A $200k mortgage is not identical to a $40k mortgage and $160k reno loan).
- djsumdog 10y ago"Oh, I'm sorry, I thought we were having a state-the-obvious contest." -House
- williesleg 10y agoApparently Trump is right.
- CodeCube 10y agoI realize that this idea is dead in the water because it would require landlords to "give up" a stream of income. However, if we ignore that for a second and entertain a bit of wistful "what if" ... What if we lived in world where real estate was not an illiquid investment, with extremely high barriers to entry? What if the monies taken in rent actually accrued equity by some schedule? What if you could move at any point without losing your equity? Crazy ideas, I know ... but via example: 1. developer builds a house, has 100% equity. 2. new tenant moves in and starts paying "rent", building up equity. 3. Costs for repairs and maintenance have to be paid per your equity percentage (so if I've accrued 20% equity, I have to pay 20% of the plumber's bill while I'm living there). 4. When the tenant inevitably moves, they take their 20% equity, and are paid 20% of the next tenant's rent payments, while still paying 20% of maintenance costs ... this % of course decreases as the new tenant makes more payments. This gives you the mobility to move from city to city to follow jobs, while avoiding the money drain that is renting (ie. paying someone else's mortgage). If a tenant stays in that property long enough, they will eventually reach 100% ownership of the property, they will have purchased your "shares" in the house. So it remains an investment that you can get returns from, but those returns do not last forever. I know, it's a crazy idea; in fact, this is the first time I've ever told anyone else about it ... but I think if it can be structured right, it could change society forever since real estate is one of the areas that is increasingly unavailable to the "have nots", thus contributing to ever-greater inequality.
- bane 10y agoSo....you've basically described how the property market works today for the most part. > What if we lived in world where real estate was not an illiquid investment, with extremely high barriers to entry? It's not, about 70% of all people (in the U.S. at least) "own" or are scheduled to own their home. There's not an enormous barrier to buying property, you can even finance 100% of the property value in various ways so very little money is even required up front. > What if the monies taken in rent actually accrued equity by some schedule? This is basically how mortgages work. In general, some of the money you pay goes to the title holder to pay interest on the loan...this is effectively like rent except better, since you get some tax benefits for it. The difference goes towards buying the loan principle, which is effectively buying you equity in the property. Once the principle is paid off, you own all of the equity in the property. > What if you could move at any point without losing your equity? You can, you sell the property -- this is exactly how it works. The new owners effectively pay off your loan in one lump sum, you get pretty much the portion of the principle you paid off as equity, the organization providing your loan gets paid the difference. When you buy a new home, you can use the equity towards buying the new house so you have to finance less. In effect you move around your equity as you move around your house ownership. If you manage things well (it's up to you) at some point, you will own 100% of the equity in the property, in which case you will become the title holder. Selling/buying a home is a bit more complicated than waiting for a lease to end and moving to a new rental property, but not by much -- it mostly just takes a bit of patience. Let's look at your idea: > Crazy ideas, I know ... but via example: >1. developer builds a house, has 100% equity. This is exactly what happens >2. new tenant moves in and starts paying "rent", building up equity. This is sorta what happens. When a person goes to "buy" a house, they typically engage a bank or some other finance organization who buys the home from the developer and then you pay your "rent" to the financial institution instead of the developer. This enables the developer to turn over inventory quickly and continue building more houses rather than having inventory locked up for decades. > 3. Costs for repairs and maintenance have to be paid per your equity percentage (so if I've accrued 20% equity, I have to pay 20% of the plumber's bill while I'm living there). That's an interesting idea. Not how it really works of course, but an idea of shared ownership. To riff on this, if you default on your loan and the bank reclaims the property, they assume 100% of the maintenance costs. You'd need to control for people who want Cadillac everything throughout their house: Spanish tiles on the roof, gold plated pipes, top of the line appliances, etc. > 4. When the tenant inevitably moves, they take their 20% equity, and are paid 20% of the next tenant's rent payments, while still paying 20% of maintenance costs ... this % of course decreases as the new tenant makes more payments. I'm not sure I follow, if they take their 20% equity (to put into the next property) they wouldn't be entitled to receive any rent from the next tenant. But if if a previous tenant leaves their equity with the property it sounds like then a person might end up with percentage ownership of tons of properties if they move around a lot. Effectively your scheme describes that every property operates like a business with shareholders. Except the current executive of the property is whoever happens to move in. So you might end up holding equity in a property that somebody else burns down to the ground or uses it as a meth lab. But you would have no rights or controls over how the new tenant uses the property. Furthermore, distribution of rents and collections and management of payments implies that there is a person who handles the overhead and management of the property, greatly depreciating the value of the property. Not saying this is all terrible, but as an idea it needs some work. In the least it would greatly inflate the property management industry without providing much benefit to owners/tenants. In the worst it would require an entire rethinking of tenant/owner rights to use a property.
- eevilspock 10y agoGeorgists and Geolibertarians would not be surprised with this state of affairs.
- davidw 10y agoSupport your local YIMBY group!
- ap3 10y agoIs this an apples to apples comparison, pretty sure we are not talking about only rentals available on the 1960s. Median house sqft has increased - how do the numbers look if we compare not just median rent, but median rent per sqft?
- aphextron 10y agoThis is just a small part of a wider shift in the structure of our society. We are moving toward a future where a small minority of highly educated, highly skilled people will live in complete luxury and have their every need fulfilled at the push of a button on their smart phone, while the vast majority of less specialized average people will serve them through various menial services until even those jobs are automated.
- Camillo 10y agoAre we? As a highly educated, highly skilled person I live in destitution, while some baby boomer jackass collects free money for buying an apartment decades ago. Rent - or, rather, the inflation of real estate value in cities - is entirely about transferring money out of the productive part of society. If you make your living with "education" or "skills", you're on the losing end of it.
- huherto 10y agoHouse affordability seems to me one of the major issues in the US. (Along with high costs of college and Health) It hurts families. But it also makes the economy less competitive. For example. It is hard to bring any manufacturing when you have to pay higher salaries that are barely high enough to pay rent. Not only that. Because housing costs are high, people have less available income. They spend less money in other services like entertainment, dining out, etc. So, it is a loose-loose. I don't even know if anyone wins. May be when you sell your house at the end of your life you win. /s
- mcgrath_sh 10y agoIt depends on what area of the US you are in. In Western PA and the midwest, housing can still be found in decent neighborhoods at a reasonable cost. HSH did a study showing 27 metro areas and the cost to buy a house. http://www.hsh.com/finance/mortgage/salary-home-buying-25-cities.html http://www.hsh.com/finance/mortgage/salary-home-buying-25-ci... For Pittsburgh, a $29k takehome is roughly $40-45k a year. That is in the $20/hr range. I know at one point, my salary was $51k/year and I was brining home $36-37k annually. I was working a standard office job that was not particularly exciting, but all I needed was to have a bachelors degree. If you have one adult working full time and another part time for an extra ~15k a year, you can live relatively comfortably in Pittsburgh, and I am assuming other medium sized cities in the Midwest. The big costal cities (SF, NYC, LA, DC) do make it difficult to own housing, but almost every country has cities where it is more expensive to live.