3 ms·
There are ideas where the concept was far ahead of the available technology. This is definitely one of those. It's pretty trivial to do this kind of thing with
by TheOtherHobbes 10y ago
There are ideas where the concept was far ahead of the available technology. This is definitely one of those.
It's pretty trivial to do this kind of thing with automation curves in modern sequencers now. In fact you can draw tens of curves in parallel.
The sound you get depends on which softsynths you use and how flexible their modulation routing is.
Most people think of sequencers as discrete notes + modulation, not as curves or functions. So the good thing about this idea is that it can break people out of that way of working - even though there's no real need to make this device as a commercial product now.
But generally "drawing" music doesn't work all that well. The information in music needs much finer control - either with conventional sequencing, or (more interestingly now) with generative code.
- JonnieCache 10y agoThose automation curves actually get sent to the synth as discrete events, with the rate depending on the output buffer length: there may be tens of milliseconds between updates. Plugins have to implement their own smoothing functions to get natural sounding results. This is one good reason to run your DAW at a high sample rate. The difference here to the analog domain, where you can continuously modulate any parameter at audio rate or higher with zero latency, is obvious. Of course softsynths own inbuilt modulation sources will be oversampled these days along with everything else they do, which is why they sound pretty good now. The Oramic is presumably using some kind of filtering on the output of those photodiodes or whatever it has, for similar reasons, but the point remains.