3 ms·
Github > Google Code > Sourceforge On checking out/exporting: I had to use Sourceforge a few weeks back: some project I needed the code to was hosted there. I
by aaronbrethorst 17y ago
Github > Google Code > Sourceforge
On checking out/exporting:
I had to use Sourceforge a few weeks back: some project I needed the code to was hosted there. I'm not a stupid person, but it took me several minutes to figure out how to grab the source code to the project.
Google Code, in contrast, still makes you jump through a couple hoops.
With Github, it's a simple matter of clicking the little clipboard button (which I think should be bigger), switching over to my terminal, typing git clone and pasting. Easy, simple, fun. Just the way it should be.
On the social aspects of open source:
I have absolutely no idea who the people are that are involved with Sourceforge projects. I'm not sure why they're still using CVS. I'm not even sure I have CVS installed on my laptop (update: turns out I do. Snow Leopard ships with it. Who knew?). I have no desire to join a project.
Google Code is better. At least I can easily figure out how to post an angry comment to a project wiki. But who knows if a given project is still in active development without digging into the commit history? (Click Source, Click Changes. Oh great, the project's dead.) It's a pain to figure this out, especially when I eventually find a link buried somewhere informing me that the project maintainer has moved themselves over to Github.
Github tells me exactly what I want to know as soon as I get to a project page. When was the project last updated. Who's involved in it? How many people find it interesting? How many people find it interesting enough to fork it?
Sourceforge was relevant back when I could say the same about Slashdot. Google Code was fun for a year. I'm glad Github is as big as it is now. To reiterate another commenter, I really hope they never get acquired by Google.
- middus 17y agoYou're calling clicking twice a pain? If the project maintainer has moved to Github and doesn't post this prominently, it's hardly Google Code's fault, isn't it?
- aaronbrethorst 17y agoI am calling clicking twice a pain. There is a lot of useful information that Github surfaces on main project pages that Google Code and Sourceforge do not. There's no reason why Google Code's very sparse right information column should not be supplemented with a 'last activity' row.
- icefox 17y agoNitpicking: Slashdot seems to have stood the test of time way better than sourceforge.