3 ms·

Ask HN: Should I learn how to program, or come up with an idea first?

3 points by LeicesterCity 10y ago

I'm only interested in programming as a tool to execute and make tangible my entrepreneurial ideas. If I don't have an idea, is it worth it to learn programming? Or should I first come up with an idea, then learn programming? Thanks HN.

victorhugo31337 10y ago
If you're only interested in programming because of entrepreneurial ideas, you will be a crap programmer.
- tmaly 10y ago
  I second this. You have to have some passion to be a good programmer. You are better off hiring someone.
dragonwriter 10y ago
> I'm only interested in programming as a tool to execute and make tangible my entrepreneurial ideas. In that case, you need to have a specific entrepreneurial idea before you can advocate whether learning programming is a useful course for you to execute on it and make it tangible. Depending on what your entrepreneurial idea is, that may or may not be the case.
voodoochilo 10y ago
if (!idea) no necessity to learn a methode to execute non-existent idea; else rethink utilitaristic attitude;
wmaiouiru 10y ago
I would do both simultaneously and partner with someone that has experience programming and give you feedback on the idea and your programming. Starting to learn programming from scratch would be a little bit difficult since there are so much to learn. Having an idea in mind would be your compass. Given that big picture idea, having someone to guide you to learn the area to help solve piece of the puzzle would save you lots of time. Depending on your idea, what you learn in programming might be quite different.
herbst 10y ago
I agree that having something you want to create helps to speed up the learning process, but also you will most likely not create something very good. So the right answer probably is learn programming by doing some rather basic ideas until you feel comfortable enough to create something big, until then just collect your ideas.

3 ms·

Ask HN: Should I learn how to program, or come up with an idea first?

3 points by LeicesterCity 10y ago

victorhugo31337 10y ago
If you're only interested in programming because of entrepreneurial ideas, you will be a crap programmer.
- tmaly 10y ago
  I second this. You have to have some passion to be a good programmer. You are better off hiring someone.
dragonwriter 10y ago
> I'm only interested in programming as a tool to execute and make tangible my entrepreneurial ideas. In that case, you need to have a specific entrepreneurial idea before you can advocate whether learning programming is a useful course for you to execute on it and make it tangible. Depending on what your entrepreneurial idea is, that may or may not be the case.
voodoochilo 10y ago
if (!idea) no necessity to learn a methode to execute non-existent idea; else rethink utilitaristic attitude;
wmaiouiru 10y ago
I would do both simultaneously and partner with someone that has experience programming and give you feedback on the idea and your programming. Starting to learn programming from scratch would be a little bit difficult since there are so much to learn. Having an idea in mind would be your compass. Given that big picture idea, having someone to guide you to learn the area to help solve piece of the puzzle would save you lots of time. Depending on your idea, what you learn in programming might be quite different.
herbst 10y ago
I agree that having something you want to create helps to speed up the learning process, but also you will most likely not create something very good. So the right answer probably is learn programming by doing some rather basic ideas until you feel comfortable enough to create something big, until then just collect your ideas.