2 ms·
The level of rigor in peer review is quite variable across disciplines and even specialties. This is a cultural thing. The code review parallel is pretty good
by ska 10y ago
The level of rigor in peer review is quite variable across disciplines and even specialties. This is a cultural thing.
The code review parallel is pretty good (and also captures that, code review is very variable also)
- mattkrause 10y agoSure. Peer reviews in pure math are often exceedingly careful, or so I am told (not in the field). Still, I think it's a little much to say that it's "a community's way of saying a paper stands up." At best, it's the opinion of handful of people from that community.